Feeds

4838 items (4838 unread) in 17 feeds

Breweries Breweries
Bloggers Bloggers
Craftbrewers Craftbrewers

Items by Alan McLeod

A Good Beer Blog

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/03/11/Illinois__Oh_Brother___Tripel__Two_Brothers__Warrenville'

    Illinois: Oh Brother!, Tripel, Two Brothers, Warrenville

    Posted: March 11th, 2010, 2:36am CET by Alan McLeod

    This is a really interesting tripel. Not a just a candi sugar bomb, there's a lot of earthiness in there. Not funk. Earth.

    It's made by the same folk at Two Brothers Brewing who made that Domaine DuPage I had last fall. It doesn't show on their website but, then again, this page was last updated on 14 April 2009. It pours a swell aged pine with a rim of white. On the nose pale malty sweetness meets loam. Not dirt. Loam. In the mouth pear juice, a bit of white pepper and twiggy pine herbs like rosemary. The label says "we brew it from pilsner malt, candy sugar and some very non-traditional hop choices." It's almost like cross between Findu Monde by Unibroue and a biere de garde like 3 Monts. A beer for a rib-eye steak.

    There is some yeast sediment in the neck. I have no idea what that means as it's been upright in the stash for months. Hefty at 8.5%. Value priced at 5.99 a bomber in South Bend, Indiana. BAers show respect but not the love. I like it plenty.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/03/10/UK_Labour_Adds_Two_Dimensional_Pub_Minister'

    UK Labour Adds Two Dimensional Pub Minister

    Posted: March 10th, 2010, 1:46am CET by Alan McLeod

    Wow. A Pub Minister for Britain! Great! Has he got a Ministry staffed with people who do work? No... but he has a ministerial task force, drawing on five Whitehall departments. Is he actually given the time and resources to make change? Well, there is that thing coming up... that election. The Daily Mail notes:

    A new government will be in place in less than 12 weeks, Labour or not, and Chancellor Darling is expected to unveil the last Budget of this parliament on March 23. This isn't time enough for Healey to win a campaign to Save the British pub.

    If this was such a great idea, why didn't the UK government introduce it in the previous 675 or so weeks since they gained power? Right now they trail in the polls by 5% to 7% but, to be fair, that is half of what they were behind by at Christmas. And is he the man for the job? While 5 or 6 pubs are closing a day 130 families lose their homes a day in the UK. Healey, who is also Minister of Housing, has described repossession as 'the best option' for struggling homeowners according to The Daily Mail.

    Sure, it's just politics heading into a tough election but that is the point - it's just politics heading into a tough election.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/03/09/This_Monday_s_Bullet_Points_Of_Beery_Interest'

    This Monday's Bullet Points Of Beery Interest

    Posted: March 9th, 2010, 1:49am CET by Alan McLeod

    Ah, bullet points. When you haven't got enough for a post there's always enough for bullet points. They are the putting green to a round of 18. The hot dog to the BBQ. But enough of my lazy blogger admissions and let's see what is going on out there:

    • Craft beer in the US had another good year in 2009 according to the trade association, Brewers Association. Apparently, craft brewers sold 9,115,635 barrels of good beer. The Brewer's Association works with an annual production of less than 2 million barrels. So does this mean when the next brewer goes over the 2 million barrel mark that we will get a press release stating that there has been a 20% drop in craft beer sales? Sam Adam's PA plant has about that much capacity alone. So, that'll happen soon, right?
    • Speaking of the state both south and west of New York, I hear that there's been some hoosegow raids down in Pennsylvania.Brewer's may be getting a chill. Lew's smoking mad. Jack's losing it. Andy makes a valid point, however. I wonder what would happen in Ontario of un-permitted beers were being sold? Likely a license suspension. Yet it does seem like a silly law.
    • Ticker alert: Guam now has locally-branded beer. Everyone else: as you were.
    • I don't understand the panic at the Beer Wars blog. Unless it's a dead cat bounce. Even a dead cat will bounce if you drop it from far enough. It's a stock market phrase. But I don't think this is really a dead cat bounce at all as this is the point: "The choice is yours. You can keep complaining about what’s wrong with the film (don’t get me started on Avatar) or you can embrace it (flaws and all) and help spread the word about craft beer to a whole new audience." Actually, no - I don't have to make that choice. I can ignore the work, however well intentioned, as an ineffective advocate for the cause. But is it?
    • Perhaps Pennsylvania needs true leaders of vision like the UK's Gareth Epps, candidate Liberal Democratic Party for Reading East. He declared "I am proud to be speaking up for community pubs, local brewers and consumers." Hmmm... is that actually possible? Can one stand up for corner stores, the local bakers and bread eaters? Maybe you can. I would also like to point out that he works for a major infrastructure project, specialising in community consultation and I have no idea what that means.

    That's a fair bit going on for a quiet late winter night. It's not all quiet. Ron's off somewhere at a festival where he is drinking stouts and lambics. Sounds alright by me.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/03/07/Oregon__Black_Butte_XXI__Deschutes_Brewery__Bend'

    Oregon: Black Butte XXI, Deschutes Brewery, Bend

    Posted: March 7th, 2010, 2:44am CET by Alan McLeod

    I am delighted that samples from Deschutes get through the solid mile high maple soaked wall that is the US-Canadian border but disconcerted nonetheless. Should I be drinking a beer that says "best before 17 October 2010" or should I not? In this weekend's spirit of not being so anal about these things let's open it and see what we find.

    At 11% it is hard to argue that this is not infanticide. The beer could easily have laid in the stash for a decade. It pours an inky mahogany with a mocha rim and foam. On the nose, dark chocolate as well as some mineral notes of coal on top. Rich and supple in the mouth, it is a light dark chocolate liqueur yet with a grainy texture that speaks to its making. Had I waited, it might have been so much more complex but at this young point in its career it has a freshness that is quite compelling. Still, over time acids would arise in a year or so which would cut the chalkiness of the finish and complement the acids from the hops. The sweet of the malt lingering there would likely break down into a more interesting collection of flavours than the present hint of icing sugar. Yet it is compelling and I am grateful for the efforts that got it to me.

    Huge BAer love.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/03/06/Session_37__Let_s_Bust_Open_The_Stash...._Maybe....'

    Session 37: Let's Bust Open The Stash.... Maybe....

    Posted: March 6th, 2010, 1:03am CET by Alan McLeod

    Stash. It's one of the best words in the entire beery lexicon. I like it so much a picture of mine serves as the background of my Twitter page. No, not page... presence. It really is a Twitter presence. And, you know, it is a thing of comfort and joy, the stash. I wrote a post about my stash in 2005 and am wondering how long before that I was using the word. Back then it was about 40 bottles. Now it's about 200. I don't like to go beyond that as stuff just gets too old. I cull the stash by giving away beer. I cull it by drinking. And I preemptively cull it by living in Canada where no one really can get the good beer into the stash either by sales or samples. Yet, they are in there. A few excellent rare bottles. Buffered by a few almost excellent rare bottles. Buffered by more good but not quite excellent, hardly rare bottles. They are in there. At the back. Under boxes. Hidden. I can hear them.

    But enough about me. What's this edition of The Session about?

    The Ferm has the honor of hosting The Session, a monthly assemblage of beer bloggers to opine on a shared topic. The March 2010 topic is “The Display Shelf: When to Drink the Good Stuff.” The topic is open ended and the rules of The Session are close to nil. You can use your post to be persuasive or therapeutic. You may choose to tell a story of a great bottle you once opened or boast of your own beer collection.

    Oh. dear. See, it's all fine to talk about the stash but to actually go in there and get into the rare stuff... well... I don't know. I'll get back to you later tonight.

    Later: A 2006 Doggie Claw will help me think about this. One of the last bottles from the unfortunate shipment of late 2006. This bottle is rare because it is hard to get on the east coast of North America and also because it was through so much with me. And because it has mellowed. The slightest pffft on opening, the lightest carbonation, a syrup body, the most delightful barley wine I have ever had. Yum.

    But does that answer the question. Let me think about that a bit.

    Later still: a bottle of Gale and Co Conquest Ale bought at least five years ago for, according to the label, $3.99. A cork pop and, hmm, the waft is entirely lambic. Gorgeous. Like 50% Thomas Hardy Ale plus an equal amount of that cruelest beer. Or maybe one third to two thirds. Amazing. You figure out the proportions. Best have another wee think about what's going on here.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/03/05/Botswana_To_Regulate_Traditional_Beer'

    Botswana To Regulate Traditional Beer

    Posted: March 5th, 2010, 2:42am CET by Alan McLeod

    Traditional beer? The only solid access I've had to information about traditional beer drinking patterns in southern Africa is what I read a couple of years ago in Xhosa Beer Drinking Rituals by Patrick McAllister. Botswana is apparently taking steps to bring traditional beer under the nation's general liquor law regulation. Trade and Industry Minister, Ms Dorcus Makgato-Malesu is reported to have said that issues of traditional beer are sensitive and need extensive consultation. Other politicians have chimed in:

    Gaborone South MP Kagiso Molatlhegi, whose constituency includes Bontleng and Old Naledi welcomed the idea saying shebeens need to be regulated as a matter of urgency, adding that there is too much noise pollution in his area because such businesses are not uncontrolled. Adding his voice to the debate Gaborone West South MP, Botsalo Ntuane criticised government's stance on alcohol saying it was antisocial...

    It's important stuff. Such important stuff that there appear to be rumours that traditional beer saves one from serious illnesses. Maybe such misconceptions are among the reasons for the government anti-alcohol campaign in Botswana.

    I seem to see sorghum beer is called chibuku when sold commercially. One manufactureer describes it this way: "Chibuku has a sorghum malt dominant flavour. There is a biting taste due to the continuous fermentation. It has a thick texture and has thick foam." Jay posted way more about aspects of neighbouring Zimbabwe's beer culture which should also help the curious amongst you but could it be we are all just needing our own thick and biting chibuku?

    So, why are there no craft brewers holding chibuku bashes? Could we chilly North Americans handle it? Martyn wants his South African beer basket and maybe so should we all.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/03/04/The_Hobby_Of_Not_Drinking_Everything'

    The Hobby Of Not Drinking Everything

    Posted: March 4th, 2010, 1:57am CET by Alan McLeod

    Good article in the Los Angeles Times today by Evan George on the hobby of the beer stash. The hero of the story is Mr. Arrieta:

    To grab a beer, Israel Arrieta doesn't just stroll to the fridge; he has to walk out his back door to the side of the house, where he pries a chicken-wire screen off a basement window and scrambles, crab position, down a wooden ladder. Several minutes later, he emerges cradling half a dozen cool, dusty bottles of beer. Arrieta, 27, keeps his beer in the closest thing to a cave: the crawl space under his parents' North Pasadena house.

    We also read about a 55-year-old who writes for the film industry, a retired medic, a Raytheon engineer from Glendale but it's Arrieta, the guy who keeps his beer in a dirt crawl space behind chicken wire, who makes the story. He sums up the hobby as "not drinking everything just because you have it" and I suppose that is why I do it, too, as well as simply because I have to hunt out my beer an buy in mass purchases living, as I do behind the great mapled curtain of national denial.

    One of the other stash nerds also pointed out that "If you just age all the bottles for 10 years and drink them in a month, that doesn't make sense." I don't know if I necessarily agree with that as I am quite comfortable with the idea that a beer like a wine can be on point or past it. I want it when its best because who really needs to be exposed to a beer that is "cloyingly salty, more like Kikkoman than a Boston lager"? Gak.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/03/03/Michigan__Reserve_Special__Dark_Horse_Brewing__Marshall'

    Michigan: Reserve Special, Dark Horse Brewing, Marshall

    Posted: March 3rd, 2010, 2:22am CET by Alan McLeod

    Marshall, Michigan. I would like to spend a few days there, drinking Dark Horse beer. The only think better than Dark Horse beer is the extraordinary fountain in the centre of town. It's a small town, under 6,000 people. So, it's pretty good that they have at least two extraordinary things there.

    I was there last August and spent less than an hour. Picked up a bunch of beer and this is one of the last, a 7.5% black beer. I'd call it a stout but what do I know. Very nice. Dark chocolate coloured ale under a mocha rim. In the mouth, plenty of dry cocoa powder and date enriched to short of the point of licorice but you can see the licorice from here. And an attractive rich consistency like the cocoa powder hasn't completely dissolved. The integration of the hops adds to the dark chocolate effect, a slightly mentholated effect. I would love to have this with BBQ.

    The BAers have the love. And now available in New England.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/03/01/Can_t_They_Get_The_Rules_Of_Betting_For_Beer_Right_'

    Can't They Get The Rules Of Betting For Beer Right?

    Posted: March 1st, 2010, 1:25am CET by Alan McLeod

    You may have heard that Harper and U.S. President Barack Obama bet a case of beer each on the outcome of today's Olympic men’s hockey final. Apparently, because Canada won, Obama now owes Harper a case of Molson Canadian. If the U.S. had won, Harper would have owed Obama a case of Yuengling beer. How embarrassing for us and another missed opportunity that tells us how little craft beer has entered into the general conversation.

    And did they even get the bet right? It is one thing for young hockey players not to know the difference but how can national leaders, at the top of their respective international trade teams, not put the best they have to offer? This bet? It's like a bet for a bag of ketchup potato chips against a box of Ring-a-Dings. And didn't they get the basic idea of the wager wrong? When the Red Sox played the Rockies in the 2007 World Series, Senators from Massachusetts bet a box of seafood and other east coast treats while Senators from Denver wagered prime beef and other food from Colorado. Shouldn't Obama have to consume the Canadian beer as part of his losing the bet? Isn't the whole point, after a Canadian win, to have the President of the United States say "you know... I was thinking... I wasn't going... to like... this Canadian beer... but I gotta say... it's not... that bad."

    And apparently even this was a re-do.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/27/Breaking_Down_Walls_Between_Producers_And_Customers'

    Breaking Down Walls Between Producers And Customers

    Posted: February 27th, 2010, 11:58pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Jack Curtin dropped an idea into the discourse today that I think is really worth exploring:

    One of the secret strengths of craft’s little corner of the beer world has always been the breaking down of the walls between producers and customers. Add in the even stronger bond between brewers and homebrewers are you have one of the primary factors in allowing crafts to continue to thrive and grow even in a terrible economy, second only to consumer perception of quality and value for their hard-earned dollars.

    There is a lot packed into that short paragraph. Three ideas really and the fourth of their ranking. He got thinking this way in response to an article in The New York Times this weekend about the ways craft brewers are reaching out to their customers. Let's have a look at Jack's ideas and flesh them out a bit.

    • The walls between producers and customers: this is an important idea but I think one that is frankly overplayed by the craft brewing trade including commentators. Most consumers will never meet or certainly not have the kind of relationship that is shared between people who work in the beer trade at all levels. That is why I like to say love the beer not the brewer. We can like the brewer just fine but have to be wary of ideas like "supporting" a "craft beer community" as opposed to being watchful for respect of beer lovers in the marketplace. Similarly, we have to be careful in response to claims that brewers are celebrities or even rock stars. Worse, we have claims that beer knowledge is specialist knowledge that requires only "real" writers doing the describing. These things put distance between the consumer and producer and even confuse the marketplace though fostering snobbery.
    • The bond between brewers and homebrewers: when I started my interest in good beer, it was through homebrewing. I was in London in the mid-80s and brought back a few books, a few collapsible plastic kegs and some other stuff. The best writing about beer at that time seemed to be all about home brewing. When I started blogging about beer back in 2003 I could find very few other bloggers who weren't focusing on making it themselves. Craft brew and home brew were connected though people trying to replicate the good beers they were finding in the shops. I don't know if that is so much the case anymore. I have a sense that the next wave of craft beer drinkers may never have met a home brewer.
    • Consumer perception of quality and value: what product shouldn't be judge as a matter of quality and value? Claims that value is not a vital principle to a beer fan sound to me like claims to a captured market. Sure there are real beer hounds who will spend stupid amounts to travel to the one pure source of that one unattainable beer but no one is building an industry to serve that luxury hobbyist. It's really about getting the six park into a million grocery carts.
    • The relative place of these three principles: You can see where I am going. For me the last idea is the most critical aspect about where the good beer market is right now. In the states, more and more good beer is getting into grocery stores. In the UK, more and more cask ale is being sold in pubs. Widespread access to and enjoyment of good beer at a good price is the golden goose. Without that event of a value-based consumer choice, good beer will be stuck speaking to the converted, to the same faces seem at beer fests, to the same names on the bylines.

    Maybe there really isn't an enemy of good beer - other than perhaps complacency - as long as we trust it is a product that has the quality and value that sells itself. This is an organic process that builds slowly overtime. And it's a process that has been proven over the last 20 years of market growth. If placing more people in breweries to teach them about how it is made is what we need to do now, well, that certainly says we are past the time when home brewing was the way to good beer. But it's not about breaking down the walls between the producer and consumer so much as teaching the consumer about the product and production of good beer.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/27/The_Women_Every_Real_Canadian_Male_Has_A_Crush_On...'

    The Women Every Real Canadian Male Has A Crush On...

    Posted: February 27th, 2010, 1:53am CET by Alan McLeod

    Truth be told, every Canadian male has a deep and abiding crush on every member of the woman's hockey team and photos of them drinking beer just feed the flame. We have commercials where the players kick doltish men like us all on the ice. They sell us social networking tech. While we have to work on their taste in beer, these are the sweethearts of the nation. Goalie gear, baby. Oh baby.

    Did Richard Lautens of the Toronto Star get the best picture of the moment?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/26/An_Olympics_And_Beer_Story_That_Makes_Some_Sense'

    An Olympics And Beer Story That Makes Some Sense

    Posted: February 26th, 2010, 2:12pm CET by Alan McLeod

    I still wonder what the average Latvian thinks about all this but at least this story makes a little more sense than needing to shut public booze sales and politicians drunk driving. Yet the International Olympic Committee is not amused:

    Nearly an hour after the Canadians won their third consecutive Olympic gold medal with a 2-0 win over the Americans, the players came back out on the ice in the near-empty arena, smoking cigars and swigging champagne and beer. (Rebecca Johnston even tried to drive the zamboni.) "I don't think it's a good promotion of sport values," Gilbert Felli, the IOC's executive director of the Olympics, told the Associated Press after learning about the celebration. "If they celebrate in the changing room, that's one thing, but not in public. We will investigate what happened."

    Gold. Literally. What's that IOC? Leave it in the locker room? Hide your beer drinking?? What a joke. Remember, these are Canadian hockey players and remember what the Russian goalie said when the mens team gave them the boot the other night: "They came like gorillas coming out of a cage."

    Yet is that what we are? Is that what the world sees? Are we really the wild men and women of the north, clubbing and hammering poor Russians and American athletes as mere foreplay for a good beer? Sadly, no one appears to have taught the women's hockey team on the ways of good beer. Does she really need to be sucking down a Molbat macro-blurt?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/25/Question__What_Beer_For_Canada_Against_Russia_'

    Question: What Beer For Canada Against Russia?

    Posted: February 25th, 2010, 12:14am CET by Alan McLeod

    There are few phrases more evocative for a Canadian of my early middle age than "Canada Russia".

    When I was nine I heard the final game of the 1972 series broadcast from Moscow on the car radio sitting in a parking lot in Middleton, NS. We won. We were not always successful in the international head to head tournaments after that and into the '80s but we quickly came to love or at least fear the Soviet National anthem. We loved or at least feared Vladislav Tretiak and Valeri Kharlamov. To fill the emotional need, there were any number of tours across the country where Canucks and Ruskies beat their heads against each other.

    In 1984, I saw a touring Soviet national team play in Halifax against Canada's Olympic training team. The evil team had eight guys called Sergei which the announcer at the rink pronounced as "Sir-jay-ee." We cheered when the Canadians rushed toward their end. When they let loose slap shots from beyond half we winced silent winces expecting the goalie or the boards behind the net to crack from the awful force of a Marxist-Leninist totalitarian Moscow Red Army player's sheer power.

    In the 1987 Canada Cup, Mario and Wayne destroyed them in a game so exciting that I had to turn off the TV and only knew Canada won when the wintery neighbourhood erupted out there, outside the windows of the house, car horns blaring to the horizon. Then there was Gorby, then there were Russian players in the NHL, then the bear seemed to fade a bit. Then they got good again. I have no idea what will happen tonight but over half all Canadians will watch the TV tonight to watch a quarter-final game. Because it is Canada against Russia.

    What beer to have?

    Later: Turns out the beer is Unibroue's Edition 2005, a 10% Extra Strong Ale on Lees under an old school "U with grain" logo. And Canada scored its first goal between the pop of the cork and my first sip. It pours a dark brown with a thin white rim. Dark plum and dark chocolate on the nose. Gorgeous in the mouth. A mild menthol effect fades into plum and cola, ginger and nutmeg, apple butter and tobacco. A little oily but not too heavy. Plenty of BAer love.

    Two nuttin' for Canada 12 minutes into the first period. Excellent. Three nuttin' a minute later. Oh my. Oh my oh my oh my.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/24/Further_Olympic_Related_Drinking_Problems'

    Further Olympic Related Drinking Problems

    Posted: February 24th, 2010, 3:59am CET by Alan McLeod

    It is inevitable, I suppose, that folks get all whipped up and excited when the big event comes to their town but this is getting a little weird:

    A B.C. government MLA is facing drunk-driving charges after an evening of Olympic-related events. In statement issued Tuesday afternoon, North Vancouver-Seymour MLA Jane Thornthwaite apologized for her behaviour... The B.C. Liberal MLA, who has three children, was driving home at about 1 a.m. on Tuesday when she was stopped at a North Vancouver RCMP road check. A spokesman for the RCMP said a 51-year-old female driver came to their attention – he would not confirm it was Ms. Thorthwaite – and the driver provided a breath sample that indicated her blood alcohol level was over the legal limit of .08 per cent.

    I am not so much interested in the gotcha of the story so much as how, when combined with the instantly beloved beer drinking gold medal winner and the crowded streets out of control, it does paint a picture of what a pervasive and intimate - yet hazardous - role drinking has within Canadian culture. It's hard to place. We are comfortable pushing the pounding back, don't navel gaze too much about it. We even make it a point of pride in any number of contexts. What must it look like to others?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/23/Craft_Brewers_Break_Ranks_And_Use_Rice'

    Craft Brewers Break Ranks And Use Rice

    Posted: February 23rd, 2010, 12:24am CET by Alan McLeod

    One of the silliest things I have ever come across in all these years of yapping about good beer was last year's infomercial made by US craft brewers titled "I am a Craft Brewer." It included many mutual back pats and self-pinned blue ribbon statements including the pledges that they do not put corn in their beer, they do not put rice in their beer. One year later, such "honouring and holding true to their craft" - as the infomercial claimed - is seemingly not so important to New Jersey's Flying Fish Brewing as they have decided to put rice in their beer... or at least one, their not yet released Exit 16 Wild Rice Double IPA:

    Although no longer home to forests of giant cedars and salt hay marshes teeming with aquatic life, the Meadowlands is still an amazingly diverse ecosystem providing vital animal and plant habitat. In a nod to a once common food plant here, we’ve brewed this beer with wild rice. We also used brown and white rice, as well as two malts. Rice helps the beer ferment dry to better showcase the five different hops we’ve added. Lots and lots of them. We then dry-hopped this Double IPA with even more-generous additions of Chinook and Citra hops to create a nose that hints at tangerine, mango, papaya and pine.

    Wow! Sounds really interesting. Who knew that rice would help showcase the hops in a craft beer? Who knew that trying three different rices would be interesting? Maybe someone who actually tried?

    Look, there is no reason to get all freaked out finger pointy, screaming hypocrisy or go over the top some other way. We just need to thank our stars that human invention knows no such bounds. And, like Wisconsin's New Glarus and its corn beer Spotted Cow, good rice beer has already been done before as Michigan's Kuhnhenn Brewing Company has made a Double Rice IPA (DRIPA) according to the BAers.

    Promising never to make beer with corn or rice? It's like promising to never make beer in casks or to only make beer in casks. Make beer from turnips for all I care. As long as you make it tasty and sell it to me at a fair price, what does it matter to me?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/22/Olympic_Celebrations_One_Big_Binge_o_rama'

    Olympic Celebrations One Big Binge-o-rama

    Posted: February 22nd, 2010, 3:05am CET by Alan McLeod

    Call the Neo-probes! Athletic competitions now proven to lead to binge drinking as Vancouver struggles to keep up with drunk jet setting gangs of cow bell ringers and fans of third-rate curlering nations. Jet setting Olympic public boozing is apparently something we are very good at in Canada:

    “Due to an unprecedented number of intoxicated people, we must do what we can to ensure the Games are safe for everyone,” said a spokesman for the province’s liquor licensing branch Sunday. “We’re taking a measured approach that still allows people to have fun and feel confident that they will be safe while doing so,” he said... Vancouver Police said they are prepared to ask for more early-closing orders to tackle public drinking, drunkenness and disorder on city streets, after being granted similar orders for Saturday and Sunday. Police spokesman Const. Lindsey Houghton said there was a noticeable spike in people bringing booze into the downtown core on the weekend.

    And it's not just the crowds in the streets who are booze fueled. We Canadians proudly celebrated the gold medal celebrations by our own Jon Montgomery, the fastest guy to go head first down an ice chute on a sled: "I don’t subscribe to necessarily all the things typical athletes do, and for me a pint now and then is a good thing,” he said... “I go out to parties with him, and he finishes the party,” said teammate Mike Douglas. He finishes the party. That's why we love him. He walked around chugging from a pitcher of beer after the victory pretty much like he did, above, at the Skeleton World Championships in Feb. 2008. And during an interview, a fan tossed Montgomery a mickey of rye, which he stuck in his back pocket. That's why we love him. He is us.

    We are such bad examples for ourselves.

    Update: Huffington Post has the photos and a video:

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/21/A_Good_Goat_Cheese_Likes_A_Belgian_Pale_Ale'

    A Good Goat Cheese Likes A Belgian Pale Ale

    Posted: February 21st, 2010, 3:18am CET by Alan McLeod

    Years ago, when I was thinking about extra part time jobs I might take on, I had this idea that I could set up an ice cream van that dispensed soft serve goats milk cheese. The brand was going to be "I Can't Believe This Came Out Of A Goat!" It never happened.

    This evening I was reminded of the idea when I pulled a chunk of bouc émissaire, a young raw goat milk cheese by Fromagerie Chaput of Quebec. Tangy creamy goodness with just that hint of goat. Goatiness is a bit of a twist for the English-speaking palate even if it makes great strawberry softie swirl. But it's just fine with spicy Belgian pale ale like Zot or the Het Anker Margriet I picked up at the LCBO today, on sale for an insanely cheap $1.80 a bottle. Tang on tang. I imagine a tripel or saison would do the trick as well. Or not. Style goes only so far to explain actual taste.

    Is this pairing? I suppose. But if it was pairing it would be monogamous and that would be the end of the explorations. And, worse, it might even be an arranged marriage where I tell you that it's the best thing going so you better take my word for it. Rubbish. You might hate this combo. Go find your own damn goat cheese.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/20/If_You_Are_Gonna_Sin__Please_Really_Really_Sin'

    If You Are Gonna Sin, Please Really Really Sin

    Posted: February 20th, 2010, 2:50am CET by Alan McLeod

    Maybe one day I will ask a bartender for a gin with a shot of whiskey as well as a splash of rum. But if I am ever in Nebraska I now know I don't dare add a dribble of beer to that cocktail:

    A Prohibition-era law still on the books makes Nebraska the only U.S. state to ban bars from serving drinks that mix beer and liquor, and some lawmakers are trying to make the restriction history, ABC News reported Feb. 17. The law prohibits bars from serving drinks like boilermakers and Irish Car Bombs -- the latter a shot of Bailey's Irish Cream and whiskey dropped into a glass of stout.

    Now, it's been a long time since I had a boilermaker, a high school staple, but it's like all the anti-neo-prohibitionist / neo-prohibitionist talk out of the UK - what the heck were these guys thinking? It's wrong to dilute the strength? Boggles the mind. Maybe it's all this Olympic chest thumping up here talking but, once again, it is so weird to read about a society where you may have the right to have a drink but you may have to fret about how you have it. We just make sure that our beer ads have no reference to actually drinking the stuff. Now that makes sense.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/19/Question__What_Claims_To_Fame_Can_t_Good_Beer_Make_'

    Question: What Claims To Fame Can't Good Beer Make?

    Posted: February 19th, 2010, 1:49am CET by Alan McLeod

    I think the forces of anti-neo-prohibition are at it again. I have never been sure who the anti-neo-prohibitionists are but that goes for neo-prohibitionists as well. They each stand for everything good as well as everything else and in the end look a lot like each other. Best of all, they aren't really a "they" at all. It's just folks thinking about something and needing to make a generalization about it in order to make sure that the equation "X=good" means "X=what I like already".

    You see it when someone can write: "... none of it will work because the ‘misuse’ of alcohol isn’t nearly as bad as the government or the corporate do-gooders would have us believe" without the slightest evidence to back it up other than following it with reference to "the puritanical anti-drinking movement." Safe to say, when you see this sort of thing you are dealing with the closed mind of the anti-neo-prohibitionists... or neo-prohibitionists depending on the brand of outlandishness foisted upon your eyes.

    You also see it in other ways. Self congratulations. Chest thumping king of the hillery. First prize giving. Now, I like Jeff Alworth as much as the next guy but he is getting a lot of responses to his suggestion that in his home state of Oregon "we are abandoning the larger quantities of cheap beer for the smaller quantities of good beer" and, as a result, has determined that craft beer has become "competing cultural model for alcohol consumption that encourages healthy behavior." Well, just as we understand that there are actual social issues in the UK related to alcohol use (even if cask ale isn't to blame) we also realize people are cutting back and shifting drinking compared to past decades for any number of reasons which are related much to the shift caused by Jane Fonda's exercise VHS tapes as well as the breakdown of family life being based on post-work male bonding in bars in favour of driving children around in mini-vans to their incessant activities (though craft beer may add a 1% shift plus or minus.)

    One of the oddest first prizes you see fans of craft beer giving each other is the "I drink less because I drink craft beer" blue ribbons. My experience of craft beer drinkers has been somewhat less purifying than that - though, to be very fair, witnessing the huge amount of pleasure that Stan got from a very small portions of very good beer was a revelation. Frankly, I think a fair measure of craft beer consumption is pretty much the same as non-craft beer consumption. Some have a little and some have a lot. In Pete's words it's about "managing their arc of inebriation in a way with which they feel comfortable" - aka the buzz even if a tasty buzz.

    So, given all that tell me this: do you really drink less? Do you drink less because you are older? Because society has shifted? Because craft beer is a drink for people over 30? And if you don't drink less than you did when you were in undergrad... what the hell is wrong with you?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/18/Wisconsin__Stone_Soup__New_Glarus__New_Glarus'

    Wisconsin: Stone Soup, New Glarus, New Glarus

    Posted: February 18th, 2010, 5:59am CET by Alan McLeod

    A Belgian pale ale from the USA's Upper Midwest. This one smells good. Either that or I smell really bad. I've just finished two 16 hour days so it is not beyond the realm of possibility. But I've been in a jacket and tie the whole time. So it's likely the beer or the guy next to me was inordinately polite.

    Medium pale golden ale under a thin rim of white. Apple and pear on the nose with a little nutmeg. More in the mouth framed in a sweetish effervescent rich ale. Plenty of bready yeastiness. Dryish ending with black tea and twiggy hops and that lingering spice. A reasonable session beer at 5.3%. Part of a New Glarus mixed 12 pack that made the trip from near Lake Superior to the east end of Lake Ontario. A respectable level of BAer respect but probably not enough.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/16/Fully_Expect_48%_Beerish_Stuff_Has_Been_Made'

    Fully Expect 48% Beerish Stuff Has Been Made

    Posted: February 16th, 2010, 1:51pm CET by Alan McLeod

    And it sits in a bottle waiting for the appropriate marketing moment for a price of 127 dollars. Between you and me, I don't really care that it is all about marketing but I also do not care to try this or any other loony strength beer. Drinking it isn't the point. Consider this statement:

    "Beer has a terrible reputation in Britain, it's ignorant to assume that a beer can't be enjoyed responsibly like a nice dram or a glass of fine wine. A beer like Sink the Bismarck should be enjoyed in spirit sized measures. It is important that you be careful with this beer and show it the same amount of sceptical, tentative respect you would show an international chess superstar, clown or gypsy."

    If it weren't for peeking at the use of "sceptical" I would have spat my coffee on my keyboard when I hit the word "enjoyed." Given that we are about ten weeks past 32%, and about as many days past 40% there can't be a heck of a lot of thought going into the recipe. Or the aging. It's all just a variation on Garrett Oliver's comment about the idiocy of the world's saltiest food. Gak even if gak with a ideological point.

    Makes me yearn for beechwood aging all of a sudden. A technique with a purpose related to flavour even if you don't like the flavour.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/16/Dutch_News___The_Consumer_Is_Being_Taken_For_A_Ride_'

    Dutch News: "The Consumer Is Being Taken For A Ride"

    Posted: February 16th, 2010, 1:23am CET by Alan McLeod

    Back from a few days on the road and I am shocked - shocked!! - to find out there is an underworld of bootlegged beer out there. The news today comes from the Netherlands but this could be happening in your home town:

    People drinking a beer in Amsterdam have a big chance of it being an unbranded brew. Hospitality businesses are serving illegal beer en masse to get out of stranglehold contracts they complain they have to sign with the established brewers like Heineken... Many cafe and restaurant-holders quietly put unbranded barrels under their taps, because they can save 25 to 50 euros on purchasing and the customers do not taste the difference, Amsterdam newspaper Het Parool reports. The unbranded beers come from brewers with overcapacity in Germany, Belgium and the Netherlands. Insiders in the drinks trade believe that 60 percent of the established hospitality businesses take this route.

    Hmmm: "because they can save 25 to 50 euros on purchasing and the customers do not taste the difference." Isn't that odd. In what other product category could a merry oligopolist demand "stranglehold contracts" when the consumer can't perceive a distinction between the oligopolistic version from a discount one? And then there is that idea in the story's headline: "Most Heineken Beer in Amsterdam is Fake." Can a beer actually be fake? Sure the branding may be stolen and now doubt an example of widespread commercial fraud - a zwendel even - but does that make the beer in your glass fake beer? If you can't tell the difference? Isn't it really just switched? Or is there something so elemental in Heineken or other macro-brews that can be falsified in such an elemental way?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/13/Really__Is_It_Really_That_Unbelievable_'

    Really? Is It Really That Unbelievable?

    Posted: February 13th, 2010, 2:49pm CET by Alan McLeod

    I have to admit that I never had any plan to attend the Vancouver Olympics given that they are thousands of miles from my part of Canada and, this weekend at least, I am in a region so vastly different from there - if only because there is snow on the ground and freezing temperatures. But if I were there "unbelievable" is not the word that would come to mind:

    "It's unbelievable," said Sukh Mattu, who waited for a table at four downtown establishments before giving up at each. "There are lineups everywhere and everything's overpriced. There should be more beer gardens." Many venues are being criticized for their inflated prices. Irish House is charging $9 for a plastic cup of Guinness, for example, while German Fan Fest is charging $8.25 for a beer. Brandi's Show Lounge is charging $10.25 for a pale ale during their special "Olympic hours."

    Are we bad hosts? That is the sort of thing that creeps up the nape of one's neck when you hear allegations of gouging. But - really - beer gardens in Canada in February? Don't you go to events like the Olympics assuming that this is not a bargain hunting expedition? Wouldn't you even pay more at a major league sporting event for any given regular season game? Look, I am not trying to defend the Olympics. There's a wee bit too much of the old goose step in its legacy for that. But moaning about being dinged during this sort of gathering is a bit naive.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/12/I_Have_Never_Really_Bothered_With_The_Pour'

    I Have Never Really Bothered With The Pour

    Posted: February 12th, 2010, 2:46am CET by Alan McLeod

    There are many things that can get attached to an idea or experience. I presume the more precious or particular the key advice, the more likely you are dealing with a barnacle that needs scraping off the hull of your given ship of life.. or a consultant hunting for someone to bill. Like this mystic wisdom about pouring your beer:

    There’s more to pouring a beer than you may think. Pouring a beer improperly can pollute wonderful aromas, cause an improper release of CO2, and hinder the flavors of the beer. If you want your beer to fulfill its potential, consider this advice...You want to cock the glass a certain way depending on the style of beer. If the beer is highly carbonated, tilt the glass at a 45 degree angle and start pouring down the side. Wait until a third of the pour you want is in the glass, then tilt the glass upright and pour in the center. If the beer is lower in carbonation, start pouring downwards into the center of the glass earlier. A head the width of two fingers is a good rule of thumb for what you are looking for, Deman says.

    I have never been particularly anal about how to pour a beer but even I would not look for a two inch head on a low carbonation style like mild. You'd drive the life out of it. But no doubt I've been a lifetime beer polluter and had no idea. Better rule of thumb: do what you like when you pour your beer and it probably works for you.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/11/Ohio__Edmund_Fitzgerald_Porter__Great_Lakes__Cleveland'

    Ohio: Edmund Fitzgerald Porter, Great Lakes, Cleveland

    Posted: February 11th, 2010, 4:00am CET by Alan McLeod

    What is it about Canadian craft brewers? American's have a brewery called Great Lakes on the south shore of Lake Erie so we need one on the north shore of Lake Ontario. We have a New Brunswick brewery that just happens to come up with styles and names for beers that have been used for years next door in Maine. Vermonters make a beer called Number 9 so, wouldn't you know it, one pops up recently in Ontario. Most oddly there are Hoptical Illusions south and, later, north. And, now, we even are claimed to have taken the "R" from Racer 5 and stuck it on a line called Red Racer.

    I don't blame the beers - any of them. The beers are innocent in such matters. And in some cases tasty as with Ohio's Edmund Fitzgerald Porter. Cocoa, coffee and date aromas with a strong yogurty tang wafting waftingly off a dark mahogany ale with a thin tan rim. In the mouth, cocoa and date and nut maltiness meets black tea and weed hoppiness all mixed together with a swirl of that chalky or even yogurty yeast. A lovely, complex beer that came in a mixed 12 pack bought at a CNY Wegmans for under 16 bucks. Crazy value. BAers have it bad for this one.

    Remember - don't blame the beers. These branding consultants know not what they do.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/10/Have_The_Olympics_Turned_Me_Off_Beer_Evangelizing_'

    Have The Olympics Turned Me Off Beer Evangelizing?

    Posted: February 10th, 2010, 1:45am CET by Alan McLeod

    While I think Pete makes a very good point about most people really not caring much about the quality or even qualities of what they drink, the news out of Vancouver has me wondering about whether I might ever go out to drink with Canadians ever again:

    If there ever was a reason for Vancouverites to celebrate, the 2010 Winter Olympics are it. If you're like most of us, you'll be watching the gold medal hockey games in someone's living room with a bunch of friends. But if you have to get out of the house, may we suggest a few other party spots?

    A list then is provided of which party spots to hit and what to do: drink, drink ice-cold Heineken, drink lots of Molson Canadian, drink beer and wine and drink at Club Bud. Fabulous. But is it to be derided? Pete puts it very well when he says most do not "appreciate the flavour, but to look and feel good while they're drinking it, and to manage their arc of inebriation in a way with which they feel comfortable."

    I like that - the comfort of the arch of one's inebriation. But it raises questions. Why should I care to evangelize to the already comfortable let alone celebrate with them? What is in that weary fight for me? Why would I take on that task with any more glee than taking on trying to convert Olympians to Northamptonshire skittles? Sure, we all know the lugers would likely get skittles right away but it's not like the skiers would. You can't imagine lugers settling for the comfort of the arch of their inebriation even if the hoards of waxed plankers clearly would. I think the analogy holds and even illuminates.

    If that is the case, are the Olympics the macro beer of sports, really not worth the evangelical touch or even celebration? And, if so, what's sport is the match for good beer? Is it really skittles or is it more like lawn billiards? Maybe it depends on the beer. Saison? Definitely lawn billiards.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/09/Healthy_Hop_Bombs_For_Big_Bone_Wannabees_'

    Healthy Hop Bombs For Big Bone Wannabees?

    Posted: February 9th, 2010, 1:47am CET by Alan McLeod

    I suppose everything will be... then won't be... good for you - and then they will be good for you later. So, I was not too excited by the news that beer seems to be an excellent source of dietary silicon by contributing to bone mineral density... until I noticed this tid bit:

    "We have examined a wide range of beer styles for their silicon content and have also studied the impact of raw materials and the brewing process on the quantities of silicon that enter wort and beer," Bamforth said. Wort is liquid extracted from the mashing process during the brewing of beer. The researchers tested 100 commercial beers and found that their silicon content ranged from 6.4 to 56.5 milligrams per liter. "Beers containing high levels of malted barley and hops are richest in silicon," Bamforth said. "Wheat contains less silicon than barley because it is the husk of the barley that is rich in this element.

    Bamforth? That's Dr. Charles Bamforth to you, the Anheuser-Busch Endowed Professor at U.C. Davis. We are told "endowment is to provide a permanent source of funding for teaching and research in malting and brewing sciences" so it is both reasonable and yet still a little bit cozy, no? I mean has there been a comparison study been done showing the relative merit of soy milk, green tea or sugary orange soda pop as a source of silicon? Could it be that all that beer we are drinking is denying humanity is the opportunity to get more silicon elsewhere? It that what's going on?

    Maybe if you worry about your silicon levels, that is. Most really only worry about their ability to just get their hands on good beer. But look again at that quote above: beers containing high levels of malted barley and hops are richest in silicon. Sounds like a double imperial India pale ale to me. Just what so many beer nerds are looking for anyway. And not exactly what Anheuser-Busch is (or, rather, was) selling. Think on that next time you reach for Old Min-wax or Satan's Own Skull Cracker. You are just exercising your right to silicon enhancement. That's all.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/06/How_Do_We_Now_Place_The_Work_Of_Michael_Jackson_'

    How Do We Now Place The Work Of Michael Jackson?

    Posted: February 6th, 2010, 6:26pm CET by Alan McLeod

    I have no real skin in this question. Never met the man but at the same time have plenty of his books. Professionally with my LLB / LLM [Ed.: not as impressive as might seem to suggest] and academically with my BA in English [Ed.: now, bow ye down before me] I am used to the idea that there are many points of view about a person's writing that should be taken into account. Today, two writers made reference to Michael Jackson and it got me thinking. First, Ron Pattinson wrote:

    Old new styles. I could also call them forgotten styles. Or the styles Michael Jackson missed. Burton, AK, Double Brown. Beers that not only were around for decades in the past, but have clung on as tattered remnants to this day. Vital links in the evolutionary chain of styles whose place in history has been forgotten and ignored. It's all Michael Jackson's fault. Or rather the laziness of his successors. They didn't bother looking themselves and adopted wholesale his analysis of British beer styles. Time for this historic wrong to be righted. But not in this post.

    A few hours later, as the rosy fingers of the dawn reached across the Atlantic [Ed.: what an amazing thing a "B" grade BA in English is] Jack Curtain wrote:

    A new film about the life of Michael Jackson will debut at the Great American Beer Festival this year. That’s a pretty major event in the beer world which has apparently slipped right under the radar, or at leas my radar, because the first I’ve heard of it just now was at the KalamaBrew website, which they in turn got from beernews.org. It seems only fair to let those guys get the site hits they deserve, so use the links to read the details... Lord, how much we lost that August day in 2007.

    At some point we have to be ready to discuss the great departed man as we have to assess all things in this mortal coil. For me, Jackson is not great because of his lists of great beers and books and books and books of tasting notes. He was not even at his greatest for his work opening up the world of Belgian beers to an English speaking audience. He is most worthy to me for none other than his least influential, first book The English Pub from 1976. It is sort of the Neanderthal of his works, a genetic dead end as he did not continue to focus on the idea of beer and culture after this book. While Richard Boston did concern himself with the role of beer in culture before Jackson, others later took up the question... but only after at least a 25 year gap. And that topic is prone again to be lost in a sea of dodgy food and beer "pairing" books and the unending volume after volume of dreary whopped together "527 Beers You Have To Have Before Next Tuesday" books. I would prefer that we pick up his first thread, frankly, and think about what beer means to the consumer as much or more than what it means to the brewer.

    With a focus on his work rather than himself - admittedly perhaps an impossible problem of long division - where do you place his writings and ideas? Was he vital in that he raised the public profile of good beer more than anyone else? Or is he a nerd's nerd, the finest sort of friend or icon of an era now passing?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/06/Session_36__How_Cask_Ale_Did_Not_Change_My_Life'

    Session 36: How Cask Ale Did Not Change My Life

    Posted: February 6th, 2010, 1:27am CET by Alan McLeod

    Tom Cizauskas of Yours For Good Fermentables is running this month's edition of The Session. He is doing such a good job he has posted somewhere between four and 27 different posts on the subject just on his own site. His question for this month is broad, very open ended:

    I'd like to return to essays on a beer style, or more precisely, a beer procedure: Cask-conditioned ale. Cask-conditioned ale —or "real ale" as it is called, somewhat boastfully, by the Campaign For Real Ale (CAMRA), a beer consumer advocacy group in the UK— is defined by that organization as "beer brewed from traditional ingredients, matured by secondary fermentation in the container from which it is dispensed, and served without the use of extraneous carbon dioxide." Viewers of this blog have read my opinions on cask-conditioned ale, and probably once too often. So, let's hear yours, and not only yours. Why not invite brewers and drinkers and bemused casked-spectators to contribute essays for the Session?

    That is a good question. A great question and more importantly a very beer centric question. There have been too many first Fridays of the month where I have had to scratch my head and ask "why the heck was this topic chosen?" or "why the heck have we drifted so far from beer?" So, thanks Tom. Thanks for bringing it all back home.

    One problem. No access to cask ale. I think there is one hand pump in my town and it's not serving my favorite beer at the place. I grew up in another city where I probably had plenty of pints of hand pulled cask ale but I can't tell you if it really was. How am I supposed to remember? I mean it was twenty years ago.

    But there once was a cask. It was a 25 litre heavy plastic cask made in the UK. A cask that I filled with a beer I brewed on 5 January 2002 and drained with two pals on 8 February - a 3.9% all Goldings pale ale. I still have my home brewing log though the plastic cask is long gone, left with an Anglican priest pal of mine. Looks like I used about 3 ounces of hops in about 22 litres including a half ounce dry hop. The whole thing was drained on a gravity drop in one evening without any back pressure at all. Note on 9 February: "finished entire cask with Fritz and Crawford - very nice and not burdensome the next day." Neither was the priest, by the way. Shocking that I did not write down anything about the pear fruit in the malt from the Maris Otter just the fact that I didn't have a split skull. Priorities.

    I dimly recall that there was a trip everyone else took to the in-laws. I dimly recall that more than Fritz and Crawford were suppose to come over. Other than that I don't really even dimly recall. That was a lot of good tasting cask beer. Oh, to be 38 again.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/04/New_York__Hop_Warrior__Rooster_Fish__Watkins_Glen'

    New York: Hop Warrior, Rooster Fish, Watkins Glen

    Posted: February 4th, 2010, 11:49pm CET by Alan McLeod

    An Imperial India Pale Ale from central New York. I didn't look closely when I bought this bomber for $8.99 at Party Source on the last trip south to the land of the salt potato. So, it is a happy me that gets a first try at a new to me CNY brewery and happy to say it's pretty fine.

    I don't crave hop bombs so I was happy to see this was 8% and not 11% or 13%. It has a lovely malt bed upon which to lay down and think about things as you work through the bottle - plenty of pale malt bread crust and graininess with a wee bit of yellow plum and apple. But it is the way the hops roll out over the malt that we are looking for in an IIPA. We ask ourselves what the hops are up to. Not much bitterness in the back, not hacking gag, meaning the finish is malty at the back of the throat. It is all up front in two distinct ways: moderate astringent min-wax hot hopping at the arc of the mouth's roof as well as a gentler weedier hoppiness around the cheeks. It makes for a very well structured experience this fine orange amber ale under thin white foam and froth. The aroma is like a candy store that crashed into a florist but not overly so.

    One lone and erroneous BAer gave a "C" review as of the date of this review. He's entitled to his opinion and we have to respect his understanding of his own palate. Then we have to agree he is just plain wrong.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/04/Where_Are_The_Paragons_Of_The_New_Cocktailians_'

    Where Are The Paragons Of The New Cocktailians?

    Posted: February 4th, 2010, 5:56am CET by Alan McLeod

    I don't often repost from the sister station but a 16 hour work day drives a guy to it. And besides, while I like a drink as much as the next guy... am I a Cocktailian? I am not sure I could even communicate with a Cocktailian if I met one in the street or, better, in a cool darkened subterranean public space. Yet all is not well in the Land of Cocktailia:

    ...no Pegu imbiber is known to have keeled over from bacterial assault by the cocktail, which has been served there for the last four years. And the drink has drawn neither prior official rebuke nor customer complaint. Nevertheless, on that fateful evening, an inspector from the New York City Department of Health cited Pegu Club, at 77 West Houston Street in SoHo, for serving the MarTEAni without telling the customer who ordered it that it contained raw egg. The notice said it was a serious infraction that required a court appearance. Raw eggs are among the ingredients most fervently embraced by cocktail revivalists who have sought out new techniques and circled back to classic recipes. And the MarTEAni is a signature drink at a bar that is seen as a paragon of the new cocktailians.

    Sam and Ella. The bacteria twins. They sound so cheery when given their real names. Yet they bring the plague. There were 167,319 cases (or "extrapolated incidence") of their mischief in Canada during an unspecified period according to this unreliable source which does give one brief pause. Yet we learn from an actual Phd writing on this unreliable source that "Alcohol with a meal can lower the risk of food poisoning" and on this unreliable source we learn that a "Spanish study of an outbreak of acute salmonella gastric infection among people at a banquet found that “the protective effect of alcohol was strongest for subjects who had drunk more than 40 grams of alcohol..."

    It is not illegal to eat a raw egg. It is not even wrong. Think about it - it's a well known fact that plucky lads in schoolboy adventure stories suck on gulls eggs to stay fit as a fiddle while lost on wild sea coasts waiting for rescue. Would we not all be comforted were the meal accompanied by a reasonable measure of gin?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/02/Bloggers_Bust__Very_Special_Beer__Thieves'

    Bloggers Bust "Very Special Beer" Thieves

    Posted: February 2nd, 2010, 4:35am CET by Alan McLeod

    Very Special Beer crime. We know its out there. We had faith that there are VSB Units out there in the police departments of the land. Until today - when it became abundantly clear who is really watching out for those of us who would enjoy that very special beer:

    Two Madbury teenagers charged with stealing from parked cars and vandalizing Water Country will also be charged with a felony alleging the theft of beer from a home, said police Capt. Mike Schwartz. The police captain credited neighborhood bloggers for spreading the word that police wanted to identify the owner of some "very special beer" stolen from a residential garage. In particular, he thanked Pat Remick of the Woodlands Neighborhood Blog, which is posted on www.seacoastonline.com.

    Bloggers, baby. That is what holds society from going right over the edge into the pits of social disorder. Bloggers who take their cues from old Scooby Doo episodes, that is. I bet it was Old Man Smithers. And he would have gotten away with it but for those interfering kids.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/02/01/Your_Vital_Japanese_Third_Category_Beer_Update'

    Your Vital Japanese Third-Category Beer Update

    Posted: February 1st, 2010, 1:54am CET by Alan McLeod

    We've discussed the beer-like substances of Japan before even though I have never had one. A story in today's' edition of the UK's Independent newspaper provides both an introduction and an update:

    Japanese brewers are launching a range of new beers that tap into a growing taste for "third-category" beers, which are conveniently cheaper than conventional beers because they get around government tax laws by containing no malt. Kirin plans to launch a new brew, called 1000, that uses hard water and contains elevated amounts of calcium and magnesium to give it a distinctive flavor. Asahi Breweries is to release Strong Off, which has a relatively high alcohol content of 7 percent and 60 percent less carbohydrates, whilst Suntory is using seven different types of hops into its new Relax beer-like drink.

    Mmmm... It's not like the drink they would be drinking in Blade Runner - it is the official sub-species drink of the replicants. Now representing 30% of the "beer and beer-like" segment of the Japanese beverage market, third-category beer is not going away and does remind me of the questions Tom has posed in relation to US craft beer's fixation on corn and rice as solely evil substances. Yet, if it were sold here even in bright shining cooler as shown above, I imagine I would never drink it even if I am not entirely against soy peptides as a rule.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/31/A_Beer_Can_Nerd_In_360_Degree_Wrap_Around_Vision'

    A Beer Can Nerd In 360 Degree Wrap Around Vision

    Posted: January 31st, 2010, 1:07am CET by Alan McLeod

    An interesting use of panoramic digital photography... if a neat and tidy basement full of beer cans is your thing. Spot the Old Scotia can, a short lived Nova Scotian favorite. Spot the thrilled patient spouse.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/30/All_Saisons_All_Weekend_All_For_Me'

    All Saisons All Weekend All For Me

    Posted: January 30th, 2010, 12:37am CET by Alan McLeod

    Time was I used to post review posts that I added a bit here and there over time. I stopped when one reader noted that there was no way of knowing when these posts got updated. He was right. The internet sucks when you get right down to it, doesn't it. Why isn't there an autobot dedicated to the moment when I pop the cap on a bottle in the stash? Is it too much to ask that the recycling bins come with image understanding software that notes the bottles as I chuck them in? While we are at it - where the hell is my jet pack? Well, if the computer won't do it, then I am forced into the analog world of doing it by hand, typing out my thoughts until all I have are fistfuls of bloody stumps. And what a handful it is as I have amassed a whack of saison(s) that I intend to work my way though as time allows. Starting with:

    • Saison Dupont: I reviewed this back on New Year's Eve 2005. That was a wee 11 or so oz bottle bought at the LCBO so who knows under what conditions I was kept. Today, I would describe this contents of this 750 ml bottle bought at Cicero, NY's Wegmans a week ago for $9.19 a bit differently. On the slug, the hoppiness is intenser, astringent minwax furniture polish meets lavender and thyme. Below that is creamy grain and maybe white pepper but hard to say. Bright, like a bastard child of new undiscovered citrus and old fine tea. With a core of moreishness. On the swirl, the beer is chunky light pine cloudy under a thick mousse of white. The smell is like Orval but only after poured over plain shredded wheat cereal. A sensible 6.5%. BAers love it.

    • Three Floyd's Rabbid Rabbit: Rather than opening all these side by side, I am chain opening, only letting one speak to the next. I picked this one up for $8.99 for 650 ml at South Bend's City-Wide Liquors last August. It also pours bright, again the colour of aged pine laminate flooring. Where the Dupont's aroma is herbal and an echo of Orval, Rabbid Rabbit smells like the white chocolate insides of Kinder Surprise when doused with rose water. It's quite disconcerting. In the mouth, it is less sweet - which gives immediate assurance - but the bitterness is more twiggy and mineral than herbal. A bit more fruity, as in good canned fruit salad, than I would have thought was necessary. Makes me wonder if there was too much Gumballhead on the brain when it was formulated. The label says there is chamomile in it. A bit heavy on the chamomile perhaps. Perhaps covering the too strong 9%. Perhaps they know nothing of Mr. Tisane. BAers have great respect.

    More in a bit or maybe tomorrow. I need some time. I have no idea what to do with the rest of the remaining 550 ml of that chamomile beer.

    • Fantome Saison: the last bottle of a six box I bought in Maine at Tully's from this shelf back in the summer of 2008 for $16 bucks each 750 ml bottle. I can smell the happy happy funk from here. I first had this back in November of 2006 and it still has that tell tale cat pee on lemon lollipop smell. In the mouth, glory. Lemon with an echo of cream of wheat, it's half way to gueuze by now. And is that such a bad place? Up there at 8%, thinner than you expect and acidic yet smooth. Bright and cheery with that pear and grape juice I met when I was just a lad of 43. The beer I always want even now at 46. Such commitment I have. BAers have a deep and abiding love. A beer that pairs well with Tennessee Ernie Ford as well as shoveling the driveway out as long as the snow's not too heavy.

    Damn. That Hennepin four is really all Ommegang. What to do? Hey! Nope, I was wrong. Someone swapped two at the store. There's something to keep this going. Whew. More later.

    Later: Now it's Saturday night. I feel bad about pouring that Three Floyds saison down the drain but it really was poorly thought out. Unless you are a person who like beer except for the absence of chamomile. Tonight's saison-a-rama focuses on:

    • North Coast's Le Merle: Part of North Coast's American Artisan Series and, at 7.9% of 750 ml saison for 10.00 sometime in 2009, it's easily worth investigating. It pours that proper pine lumbery deep straw under a fine white head. The aroma is in line with the Dupoint and the Fantome - bright citrus, pale fruit maltiness. In the mouth, it's gorgeous: creamy mouthfeel, round pale malt, herbal bitter, a touch of lemon juice acidity, astringent drying finish. The brewer says I am to expect exotic fruit which certainly could be explained as a bit of banana or passionfruit... but if Del Monte can make kids' juice packs with such flavours are they still really exotic? Plus, it as easily described in terms of apple of the slightly perfumed sort, Royal Gala maybe. Pairs well with the third episode the 1970s "Doctor Who and the Silurians." BAers rate it the equal of Rabbid Rabbit - a mad conclusion.

    I am going to think on this one for a while.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/29/Where_Are_We_With_The_Price_Of_Inputs_In_Early_2010_'

    Where Are We With The Price Of Inputs In Early 2010?

    Posted: January 29th, 2010, 1:26am CET by Alan McLeod

    Inputs. Or as the Teutonics might say "ingapüts". It's the short form for the costs of things that go into your beer. When the price of hops and malt went north in October 2007, we started reminding ourselves that when we are told costs have gone up we better check whether prices in fact have gone up. The last time we had a look was in March 2009 but there is reason to reconsider if we look, with a h/t to Tandleman, at the words of the managing director of English brewer JW Lees & Co, William Lees-Jones:

    He said that although brewers and publicans have had to deal with a series of problems including three consecutive poor summers and the “ridiculous” duty-escalator tax, they had also benefited from reductions in energy and raw materials costs. The business had also imposed a pay freeze. “We feel that it would by cynical to hit our customers with increases since we have benefitted this year from reductions (in costs). Pubs must not price themselves out of the market.”

    We have heard much from the British beer bloggers about the pressures of increased taxation as well as the particular effects of the weather on sale and sales. Those factors are not as critical at this point in the economics of North American beer. Even though prices in 2007 and 2009 are still cited for problems facing small North American brewers, one needs to ask where are we with critical input prices factors now in early 2010?

    • The Canadian Wheat pool reports that malting barley has continued to drop with a tonne sitting at $208 in October 2009 down from $320 in January 2009. In January 2010, it sits at $211 per tonne.
    • As far as hops go, while South African ones face drought, in Oregon, the hops prices plummeted in the fall of 2009 and the word "glut" is being used.

    Given the recession and the associated increase in inflation, one would imagine there is no peaking of labour costs at the moment. And gasoline prices are no where near peak either. So, if there is a collapsing hop and malting barley market as well as a 9% increase in craft beer sales in the US is the consumer seeing the benefit? In the words of Mr. Lees-Jones, would it be "cynical to hit our customers with increases" in the current economic situation? Would maintaining prices not also perhaps be?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/27/The_New_York_Times_Examines_The_Growler'

    The New York Times Examines The Growler

    Posted: January 27th, 2010, 3:42am CET by Alan McLeod

    It has to happen sooner or later. The mainstream media has gotten the good beer bug and for the most part has added to the discourse. Stories about ingredients and techniques, stories about rare beers and beers from places that are hard to reach. And, now, the story of the growler beginning with the beginning:

    “Growlers have been around since Christ was a child,” Mr. Granger said. “We’re not doing anything new.” In the late 19th century and the early 20th century, both The New York Times and The Brooklyn Eagle regularly published contentious stories about the containers, which then took the form of small galvanized pails. The articles cataloged the complaints of saloon keepers, who thought growlers cut into their profit, and those of temperance groups, who hoped to curb home drinking. “Rushing the growler,” connoting children hustling pails of beer for adults from bar to table, was a common expression. The curious name is thought to be inspired by the rumbling noise escaping carbon dioxide made as the beer sloshed about in the pail.

    Sure - if we accept the underlying theory of Ron Pattinson's good work - it's likely all a big fat lie but what a comforting lie. I wish I had a place I could walk to from my place, an empty growler in a satchel slung over my shoulder. Who wouldn't? Cheap and cheery and sustain-a-tastic, too.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/26/Massachusetts__Baby_Tree__Pretty_Things__Holyoke'

    Massachusetts: Baby Tree, Pretty Things, Holyoke

    Posted: January 26th, 2010, 2:56am CET by Alan McLeod

    The second Pretty Thing in a week. A quadruple ale with dried plums. Hmm. Where I come from that's a prune. And what better beer to have of Rrrrrrrrobbie Burrrrrrns than one with prunes - "the beerrrrrr that gud fir yir bowellllls." So, maybe I shouldn't quit my job and go into marketing.

    I picked this up for $6.99 or $6.49 at C's Farm Market at Owsego or Liverpool's Galeville Grocery. I really didn't keep track. It pours a medium oranged brown with a fine film and rim of cream. There isn't a strong aroma but what there is has brown sugar, booze and a slight menthol note. In the mouth, plummy pumpernickel maltiness framed by that same light menthol hop presence. Apple butter. A nice citrus acidity up top with a deep small seam of smoke down at the bottom.

    Batch one from April 2009. Brewery info as well as the story of this batch. More BAer love.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/25/Beer_Described_As_Both_Salvation_And_Pointless_Luxury'

    Beer Described As Both Salvation And Pointless Luxury

    Posted: January 25th, 2010, 4:17am CET by Alan McLeod

    Two news stories caught my eye in the British press today and both were about events in Haiti. In The Independent one we are told "Beer and Biscuits Saved Man Trapped in Rubble for 11 Days" while in the Daily Mail we learn "Aid Piling Up at UN's 'Cold Beer' Compound". The role of beer in the morality play of each tale is a little hard to bring into alignment as in the first case the story is a miracle while the second tells this tale of waste:

    There are some signs that the aid is starting to get to those who need it. Next to the airport, at the UN compound – from where I sat writing this, with internet access, near the light from a shower block and with an ice-cold beer from the on-base bar (complete with potted plants) – supplies are starting to go out.

    As far as I can tell the Daily Mail's Caroline Graham encountered this beer in a pre-existing bar at "the heavily fortified US-controlled Port-au-Prince airport and neighbouring United Nations compound." While it makes the headline, the ice-cold beer is simply there - not accused of being the root of evil yet somehow the mark of some sort of beast. The inequality in the world? The shame of luxury provided to those who are there to help the abject poor.

    In the other story, the beer saves the man's life along with the mentioned cookies and Coke. The miracle man "had been working as a cashier at a grocery store on the ground floor" of the Napoli Inn Hotel in Port-au-Prince. The excellently named Wismond Exantus had dived under a desk when the earthquake struck and reached what he could from his small protected pocket in the rubble. The BBC's version of the story does not mention the beer. The New York Daily News only mentions the Coca-Cola. Did he really mention beer at all? Why do only UK papers seem to mention the point. And if he did, it's hard to figure out who shopped at his grocery store on a normal day. Just the hotel guests or the whole neighbourhood? Was ice-cold beer actually the right of the privileged few UN officials as The Independent would imply or was it the everyman drink in Haiti that it is in most places? The Associated Press whose reporter actually interviewed Wismond Exantus in his cot at a French hospital gives the story another more personal focus, mentioning the beer but also saying that he prayed and reciting psalms while buried and also that he was eager to get to a church to give thanks.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/23/Who_Are_The__We__In_The_Good_Beer_Community_'

    Who Are The "We" In The Good Beer Community?

    Posted: January 23rd, 2010, 4:26pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Martyn, the wise Zythophile, made an observation yesterday that includes a per-supposition that I am not sure has been explored:

    It's not said often enough in this argument: we drink because we enjoy it, and the overall happiness that brings to society, I would suggest, vastly outweighs any disbenefits.

    Because I do not know who "we" are in this sentence, I do not know if I agree wholeheartedly or disagree completely. If "we" are all drinkers, I cannot accept this at all. I have known people who died because of drunk driving and, way back in high school 30 years ago, escaped being smoked on the highway myself likely more than once when the driver in the car had had as much as the rest of us. The fact that society as a whole has a good time on Friday night does not comfort me when I think of the six kids, including a client of mine, who died back in the mid-90s when two cars hit each other on a rural Ontario road in the night. But if the word "we" means those who do not cause harm or commit crimes, who do not anesthetize ourselves to erase or excuse behavior - who do not misuse but rather use for the convivial pleasures the good beer brings - well, I can see that perhaps but only if that distinction and speaking about that distinction is part of the culture of good beer and a core principle of the passion for good beer.

    I know many beer writers enjoy their connections with the great people who brew the beer beer and I am sure the experience is rich and rewarding. Due to my location it really isn't possible except in a small way. We simply do not have a thriving local brewing scene within a few hours drive from here, though there are glowing lights in the darkness. But we do have people who sell the beer beer whether in the hospitality trade or in retail. And they are liable for over serving and have to decide whether to sell to the inebriated and the long term alcoholic. For the most part, they take the question seriously. They do so knowing the marketplace includes reputation in the community, the "we" of the community.

    The risk-reward analogy to mountain climbing or sky diving or bungee jumping is not apt. While it is true - even without the steroid issue - that elite athletes burn the candle faster trading off bad joints for glory now, for the most part the bystanders in the lives of athletes are not affected by these sorts of risks. The participants consent. The risks inherent with alcohol are not all consensual. So, while it is true that we can describe moderate use of good beer a health food, its healthiness is defined by that moderation and the context of increased concern for safety necessitated by the increased risks associated with alcohol and the realization that it is not inherently or universally healthy.

    We should take an interest in ourselves whatever we do - increasing the benefits and reducing the harm. If we are thinking about good beer we should also take an interesting in increasing and sharing the benefits while reducing easily identifiable harm - including those harms short of full bore alcoholism. When I think about this blog writing and the thousand of you who I am told read my posts every day I sometime wonder if I have encouraged anyone into a habit that is harmful rather than convivial. I am not satisfied to think of the statistics, that "on average" I may have helped in my small way to highlight the benefits of good beer, that more of you have taken pleasure from my explorations if some few have gone the other way. You are the "we" as well as those around you. And, like the good shopkeeper, "we" need to be aware of that context and advocate for healthy and safe enjoyment as much as we advocate for broader interest in great, tasty, healthy, local or exotic, exciting good beer.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/23/CNY_Roadtrip_To_Stock_The_Stash'

    CNY Roadtrip To Stock The Stash

    Posted: January 23rd, 2010, 2:56am CET by Alan McLeod

    Back. I made it back. I hit four beer stores over around 500 km and nine and a half hours. Now, whereas Pretty Things was just a one time bottle that I passed in the night, now I have seven bottles representing three of their brews and any number of batches. Those canny little cap labels are mighty handy. Plenty of other good stuff, too.

    I hit a Wegmans in Cicero, Party Source on Erie Blvd., Galeville Grocery in Liverpool and then headed north via C's Farm Market in Owsego. What did I learn? I had a good old chat with the guy who runs Party Source and finally met Bernie, the owner of Galeville Grocery. As is usually the case, talk is about other stuff as much as beer when they find out that I am from north of the border - health care and lucky Canada they say, taxes and unlucky Canada they say. The shops were all giving each other a run for the money with Party Source showing off its new siding less neon blue and green siding (as so poorly illustrated) as well as growler pours including a Rooster Fish. The other three were as packed with new and interesting beer as I have ever seen them.

    Prices? I noticed that The LCBO sells Orval for about 60% of what it costs in Syracuse and that Rogue Yellow Snow is about a buck more there than here. Great deals... if you can find those beers on shelves in Ontario. Funny thing about a monopoly. But the real difference is selection. Over 90% of the beers are unavailable up here and are at prices that make a Canadian beer lover weep. Wegans grocery store wanted just $15.99 for a Great Lakes variety 12 pack and $9.49 for Brooklyn 1. Wegmans even had 750 ml bottles of Saison Dupont for 9.19 and St. Bernie Abt. for $10. 95. At the grocery. Made me think of Mel in Braveheart shouting "Freedom!". Then it didn't. Then I paid my duties and taxes at the border. Then I went home.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/22/Are_There_Too_Many_Questions_About_What_s_Too_Many_'

    Are There Too Many Questions About What's Too Many?

    Posted: January 22nd, 2010, 1:19am CET by Alan McLeod

    Lots of talk around these days. Pete has posted his series on the media and stories about representing alcohol use in the UK. Jay has had a mirroring series that has been a theem for sometime. I am still not fully satisfied because, while Pete and Jay each have honestly shared past experience about alcohol use, the question of alcohol and harm is not limited to the serious question of alcoholism. Which led to my comment at Pete's: "...but are we any closer to knowing how many people alcohol kills a year or how much drinking costs the economy?"

    There have been lots of bloggy points of view, including mine that seems to say that Canada may be insulated from the neo-prohibitionist question culturally. I am not sure it is really scaremongering. The question led Mark to ask how many drinks people are having - people really do not seem off line with the recommended levels of consumption leading to his conclusion:

    Neo-prohibition is an easy and quick tick in a big government box; educating the nation is a difficult tick. Some people are terrible and unsafe drivers; some people are unsafe drinkers. Some people does not mean all people.

    But is that the point? There are public safety issues as well as health issues that are not directly related to serious alcoholism. I have a sense that people aren't recognizing this. Do I care that only some do the wrong or suffer the wrong? That I'm alright, Jack? There were 34,638 driving under influence convictions in 2006. 14,517 in California. In Canada, the Federal government estimates 750 Canadians die a year in alcohol related accidents. People will pick at the stats - however, hard it is to pick at a conviction unless you think the state is corrupt. But even if they are off by 50% that means 375 people died.... from the thing we beer fans and beer nerds and beer hounds consider an innocent and, generally, healthy past time.

    Isn't the point that when you do something in a healthy and fun fashion you should set yourself apart from those who do a similar thing in a harmful way? Shouldn't beer bloggers be against drunk driving and other misuse of alcohol as much as they are for social drinking? Some may say that they only want to support the positive side of good beer but without the whole story is that really being positive, just convenience or willful blindness?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/21/Massachusetts__Jack_D_Or__Pretty_Things__Holyoke'

    Massachusetts: Jack D'Or, Pretty Things, Holyoke

    Posted: January 21st, 2010, 2:58am CET by Alan McLeod

    If you have read this blog for a while you will appreciate that I like saison. A few years back I wondered out loud if it was going to ever be the next big thing and I may have had my wish granted to some degree as they are out there even if they haven't exactly bumped macro pilsner off the shelf. Pretty Things, which calls itself a beer and ale project, says this is simple table beer but they are being coy. A sensible $5.99 paid for a bomber belies the quality here. A while back, I inhaled upon one of their Saint Botolph's Town rustic dark ales. It happened so fast, without a moment to type notes. I have high hopes for this one.

    It pours yellowed straw ale under a fine white head. The aroma is lightly citrus with herbals. I once grew lemon verbena and which I can't say it reminds me of that it did remind me that I once grew lemon verbena. There is also a creamed sweet maltiness. In the mouth, there is pith and white pepper, twiggy minty notes as well as a cream soft malty underbelly, smoothed from the oats. A bit of pear juice but also a nod to cox orange pippin apple as well as a mid-mouth astringency. Apparently no spices whatsoever if the brewer is to be believed (who's calling them liars? you??) so it coaxes all the herbal notes from hops. And yeast strains. Why don't we argue more about having more interesting yeast strains? But no spices. Sorta like those early Queen albums proclaimed in the liner notes that no synthesizers were used now that I think of it. In fact it goes rather well with 1974's Queen II now that I think of it. I don't know if it would be Zepworthy for, perhaps, even Houses of the Holy, a record I might rather pair with Fantome but still it does remind you that these earthier manorial beers like certain aspects of the 1970s overly dramatic folk tale art rock playbook, even for their pre-democratic roots, are far more than table beer.

    I would like to try it against Hennepin. I am thinking this is a bit bigger and maybe more complex but shares the moreishness. Like all saisons, primal. I particularly like the use of the cap security label to tell me that this is a representative of their April 2009 Third Batch. We are in this for the data after all. BAers are in love.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/19/Is_It_Required_That_I_Box_If_I_Drink_Boxer_Lager_'

    Is It Required That I Box If I Drink Boxer Lager?

    Posted: January 19th, 2010, 1:27am CET by Alan McLeod

    We read in the Toronto Sun this morning that:

    "Majit and Ravinder Minhas, the sister and brother who own the Minas Creek Brewing Company, received a letter from the AGCO in December about the name of their Boxer Lager. The complaint seems to centre on the beer’s name, which could be construed as using sports to advertise, a no-no under Ontario’s liquor regulations. Its unknown to the public who filed the complaint."

    Now, I have not had a Boxer Lager or any beer by Minhas Creek Brewing of the western Canadian province of Alberta. Regardless, it strikes me that these sort of questions are important in that they tell us all what we all think of ourselves, how we as a community believe we are susceptible to advertising as well as which issues are the ones which convey special risk. And if not "us" and "we," well, then it tells us what the bureaucrats think of us. The Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario has published a "Guidelines for Liquor sales Licensees and Manufacturers" [warning .pdf!!!] which may well be the rules that the brewers of Boxer brand macro lager is running into - especially section 1(3) which states:

    1(3). Except for public service advertising, the holder of a license to sell liquor or a manufacturer of liquor may advertise or promote liquor or the availability of liquor only if the advertising...does not imply that consumption of liquor is required in obtaining or enhancing:

    (a) social, professional or personal success,
    (b) athletic prowess,
    (c) sexual prowess, opportunity or appeal,
    (d) enjoyment of any activity,
    (e) fulfillment of any goal, or
    (f) resolution of social, physical or personal problems.

    The idea of advertising goes to the very heart of identity under this guideline. "Liquor" is defined to include beer and "advertising" means "the act of making the brand generally or publicly known" as well as "brand advertising" as well as any representation intended to attract attention to the brand name. So the act of advertising is in a way the brand itself. And we need to be protected against the force of promoting the brand. And look at that word "required" - does Boxer Lager suggest that you are required to drink the beer to be a boxer?

    And, if Boxer Lager can be understood to be required in obtaining or enhancing athletic prowess, how about other professions? How about Abbot Ale from Greene King sold at the LCBO these days in a humble can? Isn't that promoting professional success as much as Boxer Lager promotes athletic success? Isn't being Bohemian, the name of a brand sold by Molson Coors, also the filfillment of a life's goal for some? There must be other beers that trip up this rule. Surely Konig Pilsener from Germany or King Pilsner from Ontario offer the highest level of assurance.

    Why pick on just the Boxers?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/17/Has_An_Unacceptable_Level_Of_Drinking_Been_Described_'

    Has An Unacceptable Level Of Drinking Been Described?

    Posted: January 17th, 2010, 7:41pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Pete Brown has run a series of posts this week and last that delve into stats being issued by various government agencies and health lobby groups in the UK. It is important work that Pete is doing as there is no stat worse than the unexamined stat. Today's post was called "More Hilarity with Statistics" which examined claims about the level of drinking in Scotland. I made a comment over there but did some more rooting around to make sure I agreed with what I was seeing and, to avoid looking like a totally rude idiot being all finger pointy in the comments, thought I would set it out here instead. I also got thinking because even if a stat can be discredited it does not mean that the underlying facts necessarily do not exists, only that they are not well described. But, as I said in the comments, I am really bad at math so I am happy to be corrected.

    The BBC story Pete began with was titled "Scots 'Drink 46 Bottles of Vodka'" by which they mean per person per year on average. Pete suggested that this was not particularly well researched as tourism trade taking the booze away was not figured in - but then when I ran the numbers I saw this pattern:

    • Scotland has about 8% of the UK population
    • total UK booze sales in 2007 were worth over 41 billion pounds
    • and therefore, Scotland's booze sales can be approximated at around 4 billion pounds.

    I took the numbers from this soul suckingly slow .pdf source. I read them to meaning that if every penny of the 25 million pounds spent at distillery shops was non-Scots resident alcohol sales, removing it entirely from Scottish consumption, it only represents well under 1% of total Scottish sales? If that is the case, the variation is under a bottle of vodka a year. I said that even if I was off by a whole decimal point and the distillery sales represent 10% of sales isn't it still a little bit alarming that every Scots adult averages 41 or 42 bottles of vodka a year? By which I mean I had a gut feeling it was in fact pretty high. But is it?

    A little more looking around further, found information stating that 30% of Scots adults say they do not drink - which means the drinking Scot averages 58 or so bottle a year working off the conservative 41 bottles a week stat. It is more like 65 a year if you go by the BBC's number of 46. I got the "did not drink" percentage from this pdf. So you have 30% of Scots not drinking, 35% drinking up to the average and 35% drinking over the average.

    What does that mean? 58 bottles a year on average means 1.12 x 700 ml bottles a week at 40% that means 313 ml of pure alcohol a week. By comparison, a standard Canadian 12 oz 5% beer has 341 ml. Which means that average Scots drinker's booze consumption is the equivalent of 19 standard 5% Canadian beers a week. Sounds like a bit more than you might think is a good idea, week after week day after day. But not fatal. It's maybe what we expect the average healthy working Joe would drink in a week. Similarly, a US 22 oz bomber has 650 ml. At 8% that is 65 ml of pure alcohol. Which means that the Scot's drinker's booze consumption is the equivalent of 4.8 bombers of 8% US craft beer a week. Is that going to scare off a craft beer fan? Hardly.

    But it is an average and that is what I think is the real concern. It means 35% of Scots drinkers adults drink more... because 65% drinkers there drink less including the 30% who abstain. I think those numbers are troubling. They may well be wrong so please do your own a arithmetic. But if they are not wrong - is there not a valid public health concern where 35% of your population is doing that level of drinking. I don't really care if you think there is no such thing as a public health concern from a libertarian point of view as that is not the point here. Nor does someone called "Alan Campbell McLeod" care if you think this is only a Scottish problem. I think we can all agree that there is a point beyond which alcohol is unhealthy. Is that point been identified by the BBC report?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/17/Why_Does_The_RSC_Want_A_Can_Of_Watney_s_Party_Seven_'

    Why Does The RSC Want A Can Of Watney's Party Seven?

    Posted: January 17th, 2010, 4:36pm CET by Alan McLeod

    I was trolling Google for beer stories this weekend when I came across a story in Britain's Daily Mail about Britain's Royal Society of Chemistry looking for an unopened can of Watney's Party Seven Draught Bitter. Though a venerable brewer, the name "Watney's" rings though the recent decades for those who care for good beer as a brand that came to represent the anti-Christ of UK brewing. Richard Boston cites Watney's twenty times in his 1976 Beer and Skittles. And there is that Monty Python sketch set in a tourist agency that captured something of the early 70s culture that Watney's came to represent:

    What's the point of going abroad if you're just another tourist carted around in buses surrounded by sweaty mindless oafs from Kettering and Coventry in their cloth caps and their cardigans and their transistor radios and their Sunday Mirrors, complaining about the tea - "Oh they don't make it properly here, do they, not like at home" - and stopping at Majorcan bodegas selling fish and chips and Watney's Red Barrel and calamares and two veg and sitting in their cotton frocks squirting Timothy White's suncream all over their puffy raw swollen purulent flesh 'cos they "overdid it on the first day."

    I was particularly curious that it was The Royal Society of Chemistry which was looking for the beer because they are the publishers of the greatest beer book I have read to date, Hornsey's A History of Beer and Brewing that I reviewed back here in 2006. Well, helpfully the RSC has a blog and last Wednesday an explanation of the project was published which includes a clear description of their interest in this seven pint can:

    ...which discipline of natural philosophy is responsible for this nectar of culture, health and prosperity? Well of course I wouldn’t be writing about it if it weren’t chemistry. But therein lies the problem – who these days cracks open a can and thinks to themselves “thank goodness for the clever research chemist who invented a vinyl co-polymer/C-enamel coating for tin cans”? But chemists are the ones behind all these advances in canning technologies and the art of zymurgy (“chemistry of brewing and distilling”, dontcha know).

    Looks like they want to study the technology behind the notorious can to see what the chemists were up to at the time. Martyn Cornell's post on bottles briefly reminded us last week in the last paragraph that canning has been one of the biggest changes in how we consume beer over the decades since the days of Monty Python, Richard Boston and Wantey's Red Barrel. So, it sounds like the RSC may be up to a reasonable bit of industrial research worth following which may lead to pointing out that - however horrible the stuff in the can was - it was also something of a breakthrough in the history of the beer canning process.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/16/New_York__Rejewvenator__Shmaltz__Saratoga_Springs'

    New York: Rejewvenator, Shmaltz, Saratoga Springs

    Posted: January 16th, 2010, 12:39am CET by Alan McLeod

    A beer made of fig. Who knew? Not me. I found this in the stash and it was good. I was pleased.

    I have really enjoyed the He'Brew branded beers from Schmaltz Brewing that I have been able to get my hands on. Perhaps my best beer bottle pr0n even. This one is no different. The label proclaims it is the "Year of the Fig" - or at least last year was... or was it 2008? It was. 2009 was about dates.

    I've had a fig beer before, Brasserie de Blaugies Darbyste, but this format of a 7.8% brown ale is a better expression of that wonderful fruit that is not a fruit at all. Rich even lush with apple butter, a nod to tobacco. Fig even. Softly moreish.

    BAers have respect.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/15/FTW__My_Lamb_s_Wool_Express_Ale_Mulling_Experiment'

    FTW: My Lamb's Wool Express Ale Mulling Experiment

    Posted: January 15th, 2010, 1:18am CET by Alan McLeod

    I finally got around to making that Lamb's Wool, an 18th century form of English mulled beer that I wanted to try to make over Christmas. But I never found the time to core the apples, bake the apples, heat the beer, baste the apples and sit down to a meal of hot backed apples and mulled beer.

    Fortunately, we live in a modern age. An age of miracles. An age where apples can be dried. When did they figure out how to dry an apple anyway? Right around when infomercials started I bet. Anyway, I poured a bottle of Leffe Brown and another of Southern Tier dark porter into a pot on the stove, grated in nutmeg and real cinnamon stick and floated some dried apple slices as the whole thing simmered. I used cinnamomum verum and not the one dimensional more acrid and more common cinnamomum aromaticum. Call me a snob but I warned you. I was looking for dark malty, limited bitter beers. Any duration of simmering and reduction can make the bitterness of beer go way too far.

    The effect was surprisingly like hot cocoa as opposed to hot chocolate. Rich yet a touch dry. In fact, I completely get the idea of buttered ale as a wee nob wouldn't go amiss (...and how many times have we all thought that?) I left the swelling apple slice in the mug as I wanted to replicate the whole "eat the apple" thing and, as I noted it's dehydration was being reversed by re-beer-ficiation, I figured it would be tasty. It was. Next time I put in five times the dry apple.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/14/Is_Canada_The_Nation_Best_Built_For_Beer_'

    Is Canada The Nation Best Built For Beer?

    Posted: January 14th, 2010, 3:05am CET by Alan McLeod

    I am having a nice glass of beer. Belgian beer as it turns out. I was trying to read Pete Brown's series on "Answering the Neo Prohibitionists" but I am reflecting on how nice it is to live in a country where there really isn't any organized political outcry against beer as in the UK or any shock and surprise when our leaders have a beer. Nor is there the need to take the sorts of stance Pete feels compelled to take. Consider this:

    • No one questions that our soldiers in Afghanistan get a beer ration. Most likely would think they should get more.
    • Twice as many Canadians would like to have a beer with our third party left wing socialist leader, Jack Layton, as would vote for him. When you think of it, we don't even have a public outcry when pollsters ask which politician you would rather have a beer with. It's a valid question culturally.
    • We think it is important to ask why our Washington embassy has fine wines but crap beer.
    • We have a not too private sense of pride that 144,000 glasses of beer was sold at the recent World Junior Hockey Tournament held in Saskatchewan brining in over $1,000,000 in revenue for the event. That's about 43 beers for every 100 tickets sold. The sort of story makes us beam.

    We are a funny land. Both egalitarian and reasonably libertarian. Largely urban but the cultural myth is that everyone thinks they live in the woods. We canoe. Beer, like curling and pushing the stuck cars of strangers out of snow drifts, plays the social role of a leveler which is important as we like the level as in middling centrist politics as well as the goal of moderate personal success and security. If we had a palace of historic national treasures like other lands it would like have a hall dedicated to early and significant Canadian beer drinking vessels.

    Neo-prohibitionists? Anti-neo-prohibitionist diatribes? No thanks. There's likely curling to watch on TV, a good beer to sip and life is only so long.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/13/Book_Review__A_Life_On_The_Hop__Roger_Protz'

    Book Review: A Life On The Hop, Roger Protz

    Posted: January 13th, 2010, 2:21am CET by Alan McLeod

    I bought a copy of this book after looking around and only finding Knut's observations from last summer on the difference between its marketing and that of Pete Brown's Hops and Glory. There was a press release by its publisher CAMRA, a nibbly bit by the NUJ, a smidge from his editorial assistant but I couldn't seem to come up with a review other than the one that Knut found in The Westmorland Gazette:

    A Life on the Hop is an amusing romp around the beer world and is devoid of beery jargon. It will be enjoyed not only by beer lovers but also by those who enjoy travel writing.

    Magic. I'll miss print journalism when it dies.

    There has been much sport made of Mr. Protz but it is not something that I really understood as he is not a often discussed writer in this part of the world. So, being the good boy that I am, I thought I would have a read of his autobiography to learn a bit more to either join in the slag-fest or, more fairly, get a bit of perspective. I was in for a little shock.

    The book is subtitled "Memoirs of a Career in Beer" and the key word is "memoirs" - as this really isn't an autobiography but a series of anecdotes arranged in themes based largely but not solely on geography. I learned this in the first chapter when I thought I would learn about his childhood but where I learned about pubs he liked in around his first London newspaper work in Fleet Street - the Cheese, Punch, Old Bell, Old King Lub, Black Friar and the Globe. I didn't know what to make of it - not much Roger, lots of tavern. Then you are quickly into chapters take you through the Czech Republic, Scotland, Ireland, Belgium Germany, Mexico and the USA as if someone were gleaning through one's old note books in search of favorite and perhaps not too often repeated yarns of a wag. About a hundred pages in, I started turning down page corners after I read errors vaguely Canuckois like:

    • Fraunce's Tavern in New York dates from 1790 "when New York was still under British rule" [p.107] The British left in 1783 (some moving to help found my town) and the building dates from 1719.
    • the Yakima Valley of Oregon was once part of "French Canada" [p.124] even though the French speaking part of Canada was far to the east and I think that the Yakima was south of the part of the area of the British claim.

    I folded down more corners until I stopped around page 167. I didn't really care that I doubted his explanation of the genesis of the term steam beer [p. 117] or that lambic is the oldest beer style known to mankind, being close to beer dating back to Egypt, Babylon and Mesopotamia [p. 129]. Did it really matter that Babylon was a city state within Mesopotamia? Was I missing the point?

    I didn't miss that there is something of a cranky, indiscreet tone to these travels. Targets include Tories who put him up for the night, corporations and two older ladies encountered in Prague having a private conversation:

    I was crossing the square with Graham Lees, a CAMRA founding member with an acerbic turn of phrase, when we passed two elderly American women who were eyeing the fabulous architecture of the area. "Y'know," one of them said to her friend, "it's nothing like Poughkeepsie." Lees went red in the face, chased after them and snarled: "Of course it's nothing like fucking Poughkeepsie. It's been here for several fucking centuries." It was his finest hour.

    That's the finest hour for an arsehole, perhaps. It's that kind of small coarse tone that you hear in a far too graphic and entirely gratuitous of an account of the suicide of a brewer in an early chapter and the tragic affect on the family or, later, the naming of names of fellow beer tourists who may have broken marital vows at Oktoberfest. You may come away wondering what sort of person would make that part of a book.

    Yet he is obsessed with beer. And has spent a life following it - a life that I realize the more I write about beer sometimes can mean hard scrabble and closed doors. It's a little bittersweet when despite all the years he is not able to arrange for proper accommodations on an invite to the US and back on a liner. It's a little poignant when he thinks that when someone isn't able to meet with him because Roger is going to reveal the truth about a merger when it is likely the guy was just too busy. It is a tough old road and a long one. It's likely one that he takes pride in taking - a road not often taken when he started out. That pride and hard effort comes out as well.

    One beer writer chastised me for an unkind comment by email a few months ago, saying: "anybody who started writing about beer since 1995 (just picked that year out of the air - maybe it should be 2000... should pause. If it weren't for people like Roger they might not be able to be doing what they do." He also said that he wouldn't use him as a source but the point is still a good one. When it wasn't easy, when it didn't pay well and no one could roll out of bed and blog their thoughts within 17 minutes, Roger was out there writing about beer. He probably got you from one stage of interest to another at some point. And that is what the book is really about. You will get irritated, you will not find out the information you might have thought you would find and you will turn down corners when you find another error - but you will get a sense with the man.

    So, buy the book and share your thoughts. Just don't go on a beer tour with him and give him any reason to think you went off for the evening with the buxom lonely lush. You may read about it later.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/11/Why_Does_That_Word__Pairing__Make_My_Temples_Ache_'

    Why Does That Word "Pairing" Make My Temples Ache?

    Posted: January 11th, 2010, 3:26am CET by Alan McLeod

    This has bugged me for a while. And that it bugs me bugs others, too. Here is what I know. Someone somewhere in the last few years decided we needed to "pair" beer with food. Prior to that, people just drank beer with their food and were generally happy with the many ways that great beer goes with good food. But one of the greatest turns of a consultants' art is taking the obvious and often done, repackaging it and selling it back to you. That is what I suspect is going on with this "pairing" idea. Not that I have any issue with people being sold what they already own. It's just not something I like to have done to myself. So, I worried when I read the very worthwhile Mark Dredge at the very interesting Pencil and Spoon write this over the weekend:

    Today’s post is about pairing beer and food and is a simple overview of the tricks which beer can play that makes it a great companion to your lunch.

    To which I asked "as opposed to the centuries of simply eating and drinking that have happily served mankind?" and to which Mark responded "Yes. Exactly opposed to that." I have no idea what that means. What is the opposite of eating good food with good beer that still includes eating good food with good beer? When hasn't beer been "a great companion to your lunch"?

    Me, I've been happily eating food for almost my whole life. You should see my baby pictures. And since I was in the later end of high school, I have been drinking beer and pretty much as early as I could get away with it, I have been enjoying the consumption of good food with well made beer. I was lucky growing up in a seafood producing area of Atlantic Canada as my 1980s college days, among other things, were filled with regional beers with mussels in taverns as well as lobsters boils and early efforts craft beer. On UK trips and into the 90s, I liked plowman's lunches with English style pale ales of brewers I could find to like those at Kingston Brew Pub or The Granite Brewery or Rogues Roost. As I moved on, moved out and got mortgaged, I baked breads with beer in it as well as New England baked beans and Texas chili. As access to good beer increased along with my interest in beer, I was quite happy to pull out old cheddars, blue cheese and even things that came out of a goat and try them with any number of brews. They all went pretty well... as did most roasts, most seafoody things and a lot of other things. In fact, I have now established that gueuze goes with everything and if it doesn't, well, that thing is out of my life as long as the gueuze is in view. Get me in a room with a bunch of pals, a bunch of great beers and a pot luck of any types of food and I am happy to explore.

    But I would never, you know, pair. I'd never get into that monogamous mindset where "this matches that" because we all should be aware that "these really go with those" and, if we are honest "all this pretty much is great with all that." Did anyone really not know this? I have had the occasion to point out to food professionals that real hefeweizen goes really well with eggs and bacon and that flavours stouts created, among other things, to go with chocolate do actually go with chocolate - but it's hardly the deepest thing I've picked up about beer. So, if it is not difficult information and it is something I've known for yoinks and most I know who like good beer have known for yoinks - what is all the interest in "pairing" based on?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/09/Rhode_Island__Lager_And_Porter__Narragansett'

    Rhode Island: Lager And Porter, Narragansett

    Posted: January 9th, 2010, 8:15pm CET by Alan McLeod

    I got a few emails from very nice people representing Narragansett over the fall asking if I would like some samples and, of course, I said yes. From Great American Beer, I learn that the brand was bought back from Pabst in 2003 by Mark Hellendrung, a local businessman. So, while I was not expecting that much from a regional brewer, it's nice to be nice. I say "sure" and let them know about the special customs declarations needing being made and waited. No beer. How's it going with the samples I asked and they said they are on the way. After a few weeks the lager showed up - a six! How civilized I thought as I popped a 16 oz can. Then I waited. "Where's the porter?" I emailed. "It didn't arrive" they responded? They sent another sample which showed up 23 December and, boy, was it worth the wait.

    The lager says it is just that - lager. But it is made for the Narragansett Brewing Company of Rochester New York. Fine with me. I like Rochester beer. It pours a light but burnished gold with a massive white rocky head when poured from a height. OK, about five inches high but slammed from the can. The aroma is not bad at all - grassy hops and fruity husky malt. You could be smelling a sauvignon blanc... or maybe just recalling the smell of a sauvignon blanc. Point is this: no off flavours. In the mouth I get sweet pale malt, some adjunct corn - but also lime leaf, apple juice, mineral, pear with a well balanced steel and maybe black tea bitter in the husky drying ending opening up a bit of yogurt tang in the end of the end. It is built for cold drinking but I like this a lot. If you have access to this on a regular basis and are buying any other standard American lagers you need to give this a try. Jason Alstrom rated it B+. I am not making this up.

    Then there is the porter. As Lew said - "Wow!". It pours a fine mocha head over deep dark brown ale. The aroma is cocoa and date. One of the best smelling porters I have had the honour to schnozzle. In the mouth there is dry cocoa and cream as well as a really dusty texture. It is slightly honey and maybe even a note of lemon peel. The bitterness is in the room but minding its manners. It is not a huge in terms of body but neither is it thin. I like to think the same of myself. This one's label says that it is bottled by Cottrell Brewing Co of Pawcatuck, Connecticut for Narragansett Brewing of Providence, RI. So, really, neither of these are Rhode Island beers in the sense of a Rhode Island water source but the direction as to quality is coming out of America's smallest state and that, in this case, is the key. All BAers give the huge respect of a B+ for this beer.

    What I really want to know is what this costs on the grocery store shelf. These beers have got to represent some of the best value in beer I have ever seen. The porter would not have surprised me if it poured out of a ten buck bottle labeled by a Danish or Scandinavian craft brewer. That good.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/09/Scotland__Chaos_Theory_and_Its_Prototype__BrewDog'

    Scotland: Chaos Theory and Its Prototype, BrewDog

    Posted: January 9th, 2010, 1:40am CET by Alan McLeod

    I heard the news today. Chaos Theory was being delisted. Discontinued. One of the sure signs of a brewery moving into a next stage is rationalization and we have seen a bit of that with BrewDog. They have new staff and a new range for their experimental beer ideas. But once upon a time they were not rationalizing. They were a wee bit irrational, in fact, as they used to send me samples... including samples of prototypes. These two beers have been in the stash for at least a year. I think I got them in November 2008 along with a following email from James actually saying "sorry it took me so long to send them" even though it was free beer and I was Canadian. They have held up well. The prototype shows some crown cap rusting but the proper labeled version is quite clean. At over 7%, there's no issue as to condition with the best before being over six months from now. Let's have a go.

    The two beers appear roughly the same - medium amber orange with a swell white froth and foam. On the sniff, the prototype is a bit richer but both are raisin tart with prototype leaning towards a really gorgeously complex set of orange peel, allspice, baked raisin edgings. In the mouth, the prototype suffers a tiny bit from a drabness - even with the swirl of malt richness - which could be time but also tastes like a bit of cardamom. There is a bit of a husky quality to it that butts heads with the fruit richness, too, the aroma's promise. A little bitter and even mineral in the finish even with the barley candy playing out. Still, big and fine and I'd have bought it if it ever made the shelves.

    Theory put into practice is a notch finer. The note of the finishing hops stands out more clearly - tangerine peel, candy cane and even maybe a hint of coffee bean. In the mouth, there's a little less to work with than the prototype but there's more control even with all the bitterness. Softer water with weedy hops over peppermint and peppery hops over rich cream malt. Pear in the malt. Also big, pretty brash but not off kilter. A very well made beer that the BAers gave big respect.

    BrewDog has been doing all things for (and to) all people including taking a brash, cheeky culturally appropriate stance that I love more than even each of their beers. But like childhood's end, it's no longer all about adding. Sometimes there is subtracting in life.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/07/Allsopp_s_Arctic_Ale_And_Arctic_Homebrew_In_1852'

    Allsopp's Arctic Ale And Arctic Homebrew In 1852

    Posted: January 7th, 2010, 4:35am CET by Alan McLeod

    There is a bit of beery backroom buzz about plans to make a movie about the Allsopp's Arctic Ale, the beer which accompanied a British navy expedition in the Canadian high Arctic in the mid-eighteenth century. The film maker's website is not up yet but there is a Facebook page which reports:

    Sir Edward Belcher failed on his journey, abandoned four of the five ships in the ice, and returned to England to be court-marshalled (some thanks... huh?). A few of the bottles of Allsopp’s Ale came back to England, where in 2007 a bottle came up on EBay, and reportedly sold for $503,000 (this is what caught my interest). To my knowledge, there are only two bottles left in the world from the 1852 expedition. I have researched this ale in the deepest of all journals and records, both here and abroad. I now have a recipe for this Ale and intend to brew it near the Belcher Islands of the Hudson Bay in the Canadian Arctic.

    There is more information hanging about the internets about this stuff and not just pictures of that eBay bottle. Available Arcticky data includes the passage below from the book The Last of The Arctic Voyages by Captain Sir Edward Belcher, C.B. about the failed search for the expedition of Sir John Franklin from 1852 to 1854. The book can be found in its entirety at Google books. Belcher was a bit of a tool in an old school way but, as a fellow Nova Scotian, one has to give him some props but we can leave it at that as far as the admiration goes. He did have a thing for the beer apparently - at least when stuck in the ice - as he noted on 21 December 1852 after the presentation of a pantomime on board his firmly frozen ship: "Allsopp. That name will live for ages in the recollection of all Polars."

    It seems that in addition to filling the hull with Allsopp's Arctic Ale, Belcher also brought along a home brewing system. Here is the report of the production of beer on board starting around page 339:

    Brewing from essence of malt and hops had been practised as early as the 6th of August last season, but the general adoption of our "home-brewed" did not fairly commence until the end of October; with what success I shall leave my readers to judge from the following report of the officer who superintended. It was much esteemed, and at times mixed to dilute the excellent beer supplied by Messrs. Allsopp.

    "Her Majesty's Skip 'Assistance,' Wellington Channel,
    October 31, 1853.
    Sir,

    "1. In compliance with your directions, I have the honour to report upon the beer brewed from the essence of malt and of hops on board this ship during the winter 1852-1853, as follows, viz.:—

    "2. An experiment was made on the 6th of August, 1852, to brew with the proportions prescribed by the makers (Hudson and Co.). Eighty pounds of malt and three pounds of hops were mixed with boiling water, and then started into a fifty-six gallon cask (filling it), placed by the side of the galley-fire: when the temperature had fallen to 90° there was added half a pound of yeast, in a state of fermentation, made by mixing dried yeast, sugar, and flour, in hot water; but although signs of fermentation were occasionally apparent at the bunghole during the day, yet, from the low temperature that prevailed at night (consequent upon the absence of the galley-fire), it could not be got to work satisfactorily. The beer produced, although palatable and drunk by the ship's company, was so weak, from the inadequacy of the quantity of ingredients used, and so flat, in consequence of the inability to raise sufficient fermentation, that it was scarcely equal to the smallest table beer.

    "3. On the 23rd of October, 1852, the ship being fixed in winter quarters, and the Sylvester warming apparatus at work, maintaining a constant equal temperature, brewing operations were commenced, with the view of keeping up a periodical supply for the ship's company.

    "4. The proportions used were,—essence of malt, 120 lbs., and of hops 4 lbs., to fifty-four gallons of water: these were boiled together for two hours in the ship's coppers, and then put into a fifty-six gallon cask, which was placed (for the purpose of obtaining the highest temperature in the ship, steady at about 70°) by the side of the funnel of the Sylvester warming apparatus. In about eighteen hours after, the temperature of the mixture had fallen to 90°, when yeast was added, and generally in a few minutes produced vigorous fermentation, which was maintained for seven or eight days, the froth being thrown off at the bung-hole and received from a leather spout, nailed on the side of the cask, into a tub placed on the deck, from which the cask was kept filled as it became necessary, for the first two days almost every hour, and afterwards at longer intervals, as fermentation slackened. As soon as it had ceased to work, the cask was bunged up and removed, to settle and fine for a fortnight; it was then broached for issue.

    "5. The beer thus produced was highly prized, and I think I may venture to state that, both for strength and flavour, it was all that could be desired.

    "6. From this time (October 23rd) until the end of the following April, a constant supply of this beer was maintained, at the rate of one pint for each person twice, and sometimes three times, a week, besides other occasional extra issues; for which purpose it was necessary to appropriate three fifty-six gallon casks,—one to issue from, the next to settle and fine, and the third in a state of fermentation.

    "7. The total quantities of the essences consumed during this time were—of malt, 1620lbs.; hops, 44lbs.; and the beer produced was 702 gallons.

    "8. Although the beer thus necessarily issued a fortnight after being brewed was of good quality, yet I would beg leave to remark, that had it been practicable to have allowed it to stand for a longer period (a3 in the case of beer brewed in England), there is good reason to suppose that it would have become scarcely inferior to English porter of the first quality.

    "9. There now remain for brewing (to be commenced, in pursuance of your directions, as soon as the hold is cleared), essence of malt, 780lbs.; hops, 40lbs.

    "I have the honour to be, Sir,
    Your most obedient, humble servant,
    James Lewis,
    Clerk in charge."

    Captain Sir Edward Belcher, Kt., C.B.,
    Her Majesty's Ship ' Assistance,' and Commanding
    Arctic Searching Squadron.

    Note Belcher actually calls it home brew. Other than that, I will leave interpretation and further explorations of the explorer's libations to others who are, you know, cleverer than me. Suffice it to say thank God for what beer these poor bastards could get their hands on 158 years ago, two or three thousand miles to my north.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/07/Trends_2010__Is_There_Really_Simplicity_In_Beer_'

    Trends 2010: Is There Really Simplicity In Beer?

    Posted: January 7th, 2010, 12:42am CET by Alan McLeod

    I wrote this in the year end review but I am not sure I know what I mean or even if I mean it:

    ...bigger craft brewers and even some regionals are making interesting beers which are not bombs. Lew recently noted both Magic Hat Odd Notion Fall '09 and Narragansett Porter both of which I also found to be stunning for their value as well as their elegance. Yesterday, Andy was thankful for well crafted simplicity. Expect 2009 to be remembered for how we learned that cacophony in glass is not a brewers or a drinker's "go to" brew.

    I think by I mean the opposite of a big bomb. When I used to home brew, I was well aware that it was far easier to make a bigger porter with about 6 sorts of dark malt and a few extra dark sugars than to make a good brew with only one or two pale malts. Bombastic was an entry level approach to tasty beer. Lots of interesting stuff going on. But simplicity should also not mean boring. It should mean balanced where are one or two showpiece ingredients. McAuslen's smooth oatmeal stout. The bread crust graininess of a Hook Norton Haymaker. The white pepper in Fantome saison. I am having a Margriet by Het Anker right now and I'd call that simple - quenching, lemony, peppery, herbal and creamy but also simple without being basic. Maybe that is pushing it, however.

    Simplicity should mean easier, too. You don't need to pair even if you can eat and drink. You should also not be sent on a quest. An interesting discussion has broken out at Zak Avery's place. In which I am supporting the validity of good beer at home. Beer should not only be simple but having beer should be simple. Is that too much to ask?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/06/Book_Review__33_Bottles_of_Beer__Dave_Selden_and_Pals'

    Book Review: 33 Bottles of Beer, Dave Selden and Pals

    Posted: January 6th, 2010, 1:44am CET by Alan McLeod

    I got an envelope from Dave Selden of Portland, Oregon right after the end of the end of the photo contest. In it there was a real letter on real letterhead and two copies of the booklet 33 Bottles of Beer. I should have been a lesson to me as I still haven't mailed out the three prizes I was supposed to send - sorry Rob, Bill and Zak. I emailed them again saying how sorry I was for the delay. I may have to do that again between now and March.

    But enough about me. Except for this. I don't go to fests really all that much. And I don't rate beers other than what I write about them here. So you would think that a little booklet for rating beer in a setting like a beer fest would be a snoozer for me. Wrong. This is one of the best made, well organized, function appropriate objects I have ever seen. It is a can opener in an age when there were no can openers. It is a shoe to those who never had shoes. It fits in your palm. It has a hefty paper cover. It has information on the inside cover. It has 33 identical pages of space allowing you to rate 33 beers. That's what the book is called, too. And the website.

    The format of the rating page includes a little diagram of a spoked wheel. It has 16 spokes leading out to where 16 characteristics of beer are named - like linger, sour, toffee, floral. Along each spoke there are five points for the intensity of each characteristic to be noted. There is also space for text notes, numerical ranks of IBUs and ABVs not to mention a five star rating spot. A ticker's dream. I guess. Because I don't tick. But I can guess.

    Plus it's only four bucks. Buy a stack, fill your rec room with shelves of them after you fill them. Handy and dandy. Heck, buy one if you are a ticker and let me know if it is as useful as I think it would be.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/05/So_Many_Questions_About_Beer_From_Today_s_News'

    So Many Questions About Beer From Today's News

    Posted: January 5th, 2010, 12:31am CET by Alan McLeod

    There are days when the themes in the news do not weave a story but look like broken pieces upon the floor. I was going to consider this all in the form of epic multi-stanza haiku but there was only noise amongst the beer news:

    What to make of the noise and the questions? This must be what it feels like to be dime a dozen.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/03/So_Doctor_Who_Regenerates_Just_As_Stonch_s_Blog_Ends_'

    So Doctor Who Regenerates Just As Stonch's Blog Ends?

    Posted: January 3rd, 2010, 10:56pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Co-incidence? Just a fluke that the same holiday weekend sees Jeff close down Stonch's beer blog and the tenth Doctor making his exit? I was going to photoshop a Dalek in replacing the keg above but that would be a little too much effort on my part.

    Jeff, first as "Stonch" and then as himself, was a big part of 2007's British beer blogging explosion and the one who did not at that time have a foot in the trade one way or another. For a long time, before he got into the pub trade and my house filled with more kiddies, we were sending chat messages about beer blogging back and forth every other day. I looked back to see of there was a particular back and forth worth summarizing what that was about and came up with this:

    Stonch's: ... i might go and meet some folks at the pub now actualy
    me: I hide from everyone...

    The rest of the conversations are largely idle bitching sessions and working out strategies for maximization of ad revenue. Let the masters students figure that one out when they write their term papers on the early days of beer blogging. Jeff stuck his oar in with a heft in his early days but also rightly found the navel gazing boring. And, lest it be lost to mankind, in addition to taking a cask of homebrew on a train we all have to remember that Jeff was the one who gave us a time lapse movie of primary fermentation set to the music of Dolly Parton:

    I haven't met Jeff yet and may never get across the Atlantic to visit his pub but I've liked following his life and writing so much I did a screen save of his last post for posterity. Hopefully someone has archived the rest.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/03/Canadians_Need_A_New_Word_For__Not_Beer__Beer'

    Canadians Need A New Word For "Not Beer" Beer

    Posted: January 3rd, 2010, 4:36pm CET by Alan McLeod

    It was with sadness but not surprise that I read yesterday's interview of Richard Musson, the vice-president of marketing for Labatt Breweries of Canada in the Globe and Mail. Even with his focus on marketing, the answers come across like he is talking about about an unknown product from a continent you have never visited. Even his concluding summary gives one the yips:

    Q: Was there anything you wanted to talk about that we didn't touch on?

    A: No, we talked about Bud Light Lime. It's funny, when I came here two years ago, no one talked about Bud. They said, "Oh, it sells itself." I said, If you think that, in a few years' time, it'll stop selling itself. So I made a rule that, every presentation, we start with Budweiser. Otherwise you talk about the glamorous stuff, like Stella Artois - and in the end, what pays the bills is Budweiser.

    For this to be the situation in Canada, the fact that Bud pays Labatt's bills is just weird. The flagship brand that kept Labatt afloat for decades, Blue, has been relegated to an upstate NY discount brand where a case can be bought for less than half the price it is offered a few miles to the north. And where is the Canadian nationalism? All the beer-like things mentioned by the brander are foreign - Mexican lime beer-like thing, Belgian pale ale beer-like thing and US eagle branded beer-like thing. An interview only ten years ago and certainly 20 years ago like this would have led to an immediate firing after outraged public outcry and even mockery of the very idea that Canadian beer is not the best in the world... even if it wasn't. It's like Canadian Tire no longer selling canoes, telling the market place that bass boats are all that people really want. Why doesn't the interviewer even raise the question?

    And then there is that final point: how far do these trends have to go before we get to stop using the word "beer" to describe these fluids? How different is Bud Light Lime from Zima anyway?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/02/S35__Looking_Back_And_Looking_Forward_And_Asking_Why'

    S35: Looking Back And Looking Forward And Asking Why

    Posted: January 2nd, 2010, 8:24pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Here we go again - session time on the first Friday of the month. Except it's Saturday now. The question was posed by Christina Perozzi and Hallie Beaune, the authors of The Naked Pint:

    So we want to know what was your best and worst of beer for 2009? What beer mistakes did you make? What beer resolutions do you have for 2010? What are your beer regrets and embarrassing moments? What are you hoping to change about your beer experience in 2010?

    I don't know what to make of those questions. Beer mistakes? Maybe taking beer too seriously. But did I do that? Maybe having too much some days. But I don't think I did - I am fairly moderate and tried not to over do. Who wants a hangover?

    Is there a question behind the questions we should ask? Can beer play a role such that there are personal bests and worsts? Personal regrets and embarrassments? If we are in that level of relationship with a recreational mind altering substance... is that good? Of all my hobby interests, beer is the least obsessive in a way because it is light entertainment. Science fiction is immersive, political blogging is naively important, sports fandom creates something of one's identity for better or worse. Even with all the interest in beer and health or highway safety or questions of value or the simmering politics of even writing about beer, I've been writing this blog not so much as an exploration of beer but as an exercise in exploring my own relationship with the stuff. I don't know if I have learned enough to know whether or not the whole thing is not a regret or an embarrassment. A mistake.

    Or not. Don't know. After six years, can I expect that this new year will come with any breakthrough?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2010/01/01/Belgium__Oude_Geuze__Drie_Fonteinen__Beersel'

    Belgium: Oude Geuze, Drie Fonteinen, Beersel

    Posted: January 1st, 2010, 5:36am CET by Alan McLeod

    New Year's Eve. You want a cork on New Year's Eve, right? This wee pal says it was bottled on 17 January 2006 but it's not going to make its fourth birthday. The Shelton Bros label assures me that it would be good for a full decade but who knows where we'll all be in 2016. And where would that bit of musty mould on outside the cork underneath the capsule have advanced it I had left it longer?

    A fairly gentle pop leads to a glass filled with faintly oranged straw toned beer under an inch thick billowing egg white head. One the schnoz, there is tart Gravenstein apple, well balanced earthy barnyard funk and an odd note like sardines. All balanced within that g(u)euze sense of balance - meaning wildly unbalanced. I could smell this all day. Daub small drops on my wrists to get me through the workday. In the mouth, it is all where it should be. Modest carbonation, some juicy fruit that adds refreshment even with the seam of bone drying acidity, then in the second half of the mouthful, there is mineral in the Riesling sort of mineral way. No sardines but lots of unsweetened under-ripe white grapefruit pith - the white stuff. Good thing that there are no sardine notes as that is one thing I am not missing. Not acidic enough to warrant Rolaids or anything but pretty damn tart. Like a bubbly light fino sherry without all that sherry stuff.

    It would have been good to allow it to play with others tonight for a little compare and contrast but my geuze stocks are down to one panic bottle of Girardin in case the radio reports we have 48 minutes to live. BAers have a fine romance going on. If I had started my sour beer studies with this rather than that bastard of a beer Bruocsella 1900 Grand Cru by Cantillon I might have gotten off to a better start. More from the brewery here if you can read -3 font. They refer to the "sennois" taste which, in my poor Wikipedia French seems to mean the sweat of working class recreational league athletes.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/31/Quebec__Weizenbock__Trois_Mousquetaires__Brossard'

    Quebec: Weizenbock, Trois Mousquetaires, Brossard

    Posted: December 31st, 2009, 3:01am CET by Alan McLeod

    Eleven percent. Year old Quebec weizenbock picked up last April for $7.99 for 750 ml at Marche Jovi. A lot for a little.

    Fortunately, it's extremely yum. A bit of a cross between a quad and the classic wheat double bock or weizenbock, Aventinus. The aromas are of pumpernickel and dark cherry with maybe even a rich deep pipe tobacco thing. In the mouth, very lush soft watery even with the well covered boozy burn and the heavy body. Date and nutmeg. Honey and cocoa. White pepper and dark cherry. Rough and earthy on the finish. Quite extraordinary.

    Big BAer respect.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/30/What_Was_My_Best_Beer_Thing_Of_2009_'

    What Was My Best Beer Thing Of 2009?

    Posted: December 30th, 2009, 12:19am CET by Alan McLeod

    It has been a good year both inside and outside that beery part of my life. It is hard to measure what that means in some ways as If I was reporting to higher authority, I can state that I have put good beer in the hands and glasses of more of the uninitiated than in earlier years. It is a good thing to do but I am not reporting to any higher authority, just noting for myself and those of you that care about what I have seen and enjoyed in 2009:

    • Best Beer Books. This has been a phenomenal year for books on beer. I name three of the best. Pete Brown's Hops and Glory, supposedly an examination of the route IPA took in the early years of its travels from Britain to India, is actually a book about Pete. Ben McFarland's World's Best Beers has updated the bazillion beer review format and breathed new life into what had become a bit of a musty concept. Beaumont and Morin in The Beerbistro Cookbook have given us the best book on beer and food which, while suggesting recommendations, has saved us from the shackles of overly specific "pairings" instead encouraging us all not only to explore beer but to explore with a sense of one's own taste.

    • Best Beer Trend: It has to be the setting of the sun on the tyranny of extreme. Finally, beer is learning what everyone but skate boarding thirty-year olds know: extreme may be more than a gimmick but not very much more. Few beer fans are really begging for even more hops and booze and barrels in 2010. Conversely, bigger craft brewers and even some regionals are making interesting beers which are not bombs. Lew recently noted both Magic Hat Odd Notion Fall '09 and Narragansett Porter both of which I also found to be stunning for their value as well as their elegance. Yesterday, Andy was thankful for well crafted simplicity. Expect 2009 to be remembered for how we learned that cacophony in glass is not a brewers or a drinker's "go to" brew.

    • Best Beer News. What is beer news that isn't brewery PR, advocacy group paranoia or corner store failed robbery? Not much really but that does not make it a waste of time. The biggest beer news was Obama having a brew courtside last March. Best saucy beer news was the announcement that BrewDog complained on itself to the shadowy Portman Group, aka the competition. Other than that, it's all about naked drunk frosh being caught on security cameras at corner stores in Kansas. Jay has a better list of big news stories of 2009 - though I have to admit that Beer Wars is more likely to turn out to be the Ishtar of beer documentaries. It was news because of the irritating PR.

    • Best Bodyslam Of Beer Pros By Beer Bloggers. This is a new category for 2009. First we had the ridiculous lecture from small market western Massachusetts beer columnist George Lenker whose pomposity triggered a response that Stan anointed as "The Beer Link of the Month (or Maybe 2009)" which made me get all verklempt... seriously... but which saw George drowning in his attempts to explain while sorta still insulting people. Then, we had Roger Protz, one of at least the top 20 beer authorities on the planet, freaking out over Brewdog and then get all superior and "begone you plebs" over bloggers correctly pointing out how little he understood the topic at hand. Then, just this week, we hear that there is some guy called Alan Brewer going all "pro" on poor old Max the Pivní Filosof alleging that, by hiring Max a mere a beer blogger, a Spanish beer magazine has "allowed the fox into the hen-house" and says that "if the hiring standards of the magazine have fallen so low, he could recommend a homeless man he knows, who is an expert in strong canned beers of less than a dollar."

      Sounds like a call for a good rumble of rock, paper, scissors between paper based semi-pros and web based semi-pros. Cherry belly time. Because let's be frank. There are about 12 people in the world who really make a real living from writing about beer. The rest have other business interests in the hospitality world, a separate professional career or sources of other family income and patience. And there is that other thing: the Internet is not going anywhere. It's a good thing, too, because anyone who says that the quantity and quality of beer writing on the web is not a good thing is a fool. A rising tide raises all ships and the more good discourse about good beer the better.

    I'll leave it at there for now. I think I have picked a beer of the year and a beer photo of the year for more than half a decade now and who am I to break the rules of convention even when it is my own.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/28/What_To_Do_During_With_This_Break_From_Beer_'

    What To Do During With This Break From Beer?

    Posted: December 28th, 2009, 3:46pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Being a serial obsessive, it is not a surprise to me that I have spent years drilling down into my interest in beer. I've done this before. Somewhere in the house is my pre-internet map collection. I would pore over detailed maps I had mailed from all over the world as I followed the news on shortwave radio. Somewhere else is the hockey card collection, the 60's and 70s British sci-fi DVD and VHS collection, the soccer jersey collection and the who knows what else collection. For most of my adult life I have been fixated on something or other and usually more than one at one time. Heck, I have two banjos and play neither well.

    But, like a summer camping weekend that gets you away from the computer, the break in the action as you get at Christmas it makes you think. Traffic at Facebook, Twitter and the hits to my blogs all dive as soon as Christmas Eve comes and only come up for air sometime around January 5. The break from thinking, planning, hatching schemes is the best part of the season. Time stands still because there really isn't much needing done - and not much needing escaping from. The information super highway sorta loses its point at times like this.

    All this wondering about the cause of seasonal internet disinterest dissipates as soon as I cross reference the web stats to the human work week. All my writing, my beery activity - it's all just desk jockey day dream porn. Should this be a surprise? Should I feel badly that I contribute 0.000073% of the western world's productivity lost to surfing web sites? Not really but it does make you wonder. I used to say that if I didn't do this I would have learned Finnish (not to mention the banjo) by now but, if my activities at Christmas are any indication, the beer blog writing and reading and stuff are not a surrogate for long lost productive activity so much as a veneer over a deep and abiding commitment to unproductive inactivity. It's obvious. I haven't even been spending the time off in an armchair considering any new beer, reading any new beer books or even wandering off to pubs. It's not what I do. I wonder how much I really like this stuff at all.

    The beery web we weave will pick up again I suppose. The hunt for another story about an off beat brewer. The thing I notice in that dubbel I haven't noticed before. But I don't mind that my obsession goes quiet at Christmas so that the more important things in life get a chance at my time - like naps, watching cartoons with the preschoolers or picking up the banjo... or the other one for that matter.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/27/Belgium__Christmas_Ale__St._Bernardus__Watou'

    Belgium: Christmas Ale, St. Bernardus, Watou

    Posted: December 27th, 2009, 1:14am CET by Alan McLeod

    I had this stuck away as a nod to Ron, the patron saint of Watou. As I can't get the 12 on tap, this is according to Ron the second best thing.

    And it is a best thing. Brownest brew under rich deep cream froth and foam. A nose of dark plum and date with cinnamon and nutmeg. All that plus cream, a little burlap and a boozy tingle in the mouth. Just the thing for sherry trifle not to mention the Leafs and Habs on Boxing Day. At 10% - pun warning - it is not to be trifled with even if trifle goes with it. Say what you like about puns but it is true. These Christmas scale large format bottles are powerful beasts in velvet garb. Not sure that I could open a second. Like drinking gravy if gravy was a by-product of the cake and icing making process. Licorice and thyme in the malt laden finish.

    BAers love it.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/26/Michigan__Weizen_Bam__Jolly_Pumkin__Dexter'

    Michigan: Weizen Bam, Jolly Pumkin, Dexter

    Posted: December 26th, 2009, 3:51am CET by Alan McLeod

    It's been all too much, really. The photo contest, plus the shopping, then the work lunches and drinks and then shopping and the seminars and concerts and church and... now it's Christmas night. Present opened, lamb consumed, half the kids in bed and the rest headed that way. What to have to cut the cloy of these rich days?

    Jolly Pumpkin's Weizen Bam clocks in at a mere 4.5%. It pours quite pale gold with a pure white head sustained by some pretty active carbonation. The aroma is full of zesty, acidic herbals and citrus. In the mouth it is semi-dry with rice wine vinegar and lemon juice zip but still some light malt presence along with a bit of spice. Recessed yeastiness imparting some light banana thing but this is no tribute to hefeweizen so much as a nod to it from a stack of oak barrels. Completely refreshing. One might even use the word zing in one form or another. Bought for a bargain at the brewery last August. Plenty of BAer love.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/24/Don_t_Forget_To_Heat_Your_Beer_For_Christmas'

    Don't Forget To Heat Your Beer For Christmas

    Posted: December 24th, 2009, 4:18am CET by Alan McLeod

    The Washington Post introduced a piece on Christmas ales today with a reminder that they harken back to the pre-Puritan days of England, days of steaming bowls of hot spiced ale and shorter life spans:

    ... originally, the word -- from the Middle English greeting "waes haeil," or "be hearty" -- referred to the strong drink that inspired enthusiastic if tone-deaf renditions of "God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen" and "Good King Wenceslas." Wassail was a freestyle punch made with a strong spiced ale (sometimes wine) and flavored with sugar, nutmeg, cloves, apples, oranges, toast; in short, whatever the lord of the manor might have lying about his pantry. During the Christmas season, it was customary to offer a warming drink to bands of carolers. In 1644, the Puritans in England banned the practice (and all other public celebrations of Christmas) on the grounds that it led to wastefulness and debauchery.

    Screw you, Cromwell. I have been wanting to heat some beer for the heck of it this Yuletide and think I will make a drink called a Lamb's Wool. My copy of Acton and Duncan's Making Mead tells me a good Lamb's Wool starts with baking apples with honey and nutmeg in the oven, then pouring two quarts of brown over them when done and ladling it over the apples on the stove until it all piping hot after which the apples are eaten with a jug of the hot sweetened spiced ale. Excellent - a beer that is also a good source of dietary fibre.

    Now, which beer to wrack with such punishment? I am sure as heck not going to experiment with something expensive but here in Ontario you can pick up a 750 ml of 8% Maudit by Unibrou for about five and a half bucks. It's also a bit dry for a dubbel sThat should do the trick. The apple variety would make a difference as well. I am thinking an earthy Russet or a sharp Northern Spy. I am not thinking Golden Delicious. An apple should taste like something. Like, you know, an apple.

    Anyone else planning a mulled ale?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/22/My_First_Hospitality_Seminar___And_What_Do_I_Say_'

    My First Hospitality Seminar - And What Do I Say?

    Posted: December 22nd, 2009, 1:32pm CET by Alan McLeod

    I like to think I know a thing or two about beer but I probably know diddly when it comes down to it. I go on here and yak at other people's blogs but have I really been put to the test? Well, I have been invited to lead local folk in the hospitality trade through an introduction to good beer and I took up the challenge seeing both that the stash needs a little culling and I need a break from shopping. Even though they are rookies to good beer, I was actually getting a little nervous about what I would say... but then I realized that I am the guy bringing all the free beer and, in the world of guys, that makes me the greatest guy in the room if not all of the town. Here is what I have learned so far:

    • Good beer is cheap. I have only about ten people coming and in gathering my part of the gift of good beer I probably spent 75 bucks to gather about 50 or 75 generous sample servings splitting 500 ml two or three ways. We grumble sometimes about the LCBO but we are pretty lucky to have that as well as borders you can cross to get the rest.
    • We have good beer available to us even if beer hounds hunting for the next tick might grumble. The selection include London Pride, Ontario's 10W30 by Neustadt, Beau's Lugtread, Unibrou's Maudit, Westmalle Dubbel, Brooklyn Chocolate Stout, Aventinus Eisbock, Weihenstephaner Weissbier as well as one smokey bottle of Schlenkerla Rauchbier, my ribeye marinade. I decided to lean on the available as it does no good to get people revved up and then tell them how they can't buy it.
    • I plan to illustrate usefulness. For all the talk on travel, styles, authenticity, ticking or pairing at the end of the day all that matters is whether your beer is useful. And the use of beer is generating conviviality. At it's best it is a easily bought, readily accessible, social lubricant that enhances the moment with ease. That moment may include good food, attention being paid to the beer or it may be a moment where people stand around and talk or watch the game. It is all convivial.
    • I plan to cheat. I am taking my laptop as well as Oliver's Brewmaster's Table, Beaumont's The Beerbistro Cookbook, McFarland's World's Best Beers and a few more gems by Stan, Lew and others to illustrate how much information there is available to restaurateurs - and, again, on the cheap. Two hundred bucks gets the start of a good beer library for any bar and even its customers.

    There may be more beer, too, as I will raid the stash for some examples of the pricier stuff - you know, those bottles that cost about as much as an Australian mass marketed plonk - and we are praying that the box with Panil and other fabulous samples to make it here via FedEx care of the continuing kindness of Roland and Russell.

    The goal is to see if I can start help my town take it up a notch by helping spread the news to those who can, in turn, share it on. I am planning to talk about simple and complex, price and value, import and local, bottle and tap, temperature and glassware as well as simply versatility by having a beer with an egg, a piece of cheese or chocolate as well as a bunch of other stuff. I may be no fan of "pairing" but I sure do like eating and drinking. So, my question to you is this: what else would you talk about and make sure was in the room? Even if this is more of a working session than a tasting - whatever that is - it needs to tell the story well. What would you want me to tell people who can start rolling out the barrels if they get the message?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/22/When_You_Can_t_Say__Good__Just_Say__World_Class_'

    When You Can't Say "Good" Just Say "World Class"

    Posted: December 22nd, 2009, 1:50am CET by Alan McLeod

    Stan has asked questions at his blog that have me quite puzzled. It's about some weird idea that a beer could be "world class" as if that is the apex of some sort of sliding scale of swellness.There are a lot of words or phrases like "world class" that are equally meaningless even if not synonyms - "top" and "foremost" not to mention "aficionado" and "connoisseur" come to mind for similar trembling vacuity. At least "favorite" means someone actually likes whatever we are talking about.

    A teacher of mine once used a trick to get his students to stop using "very" which was a variation on having us interchange "frigging" for "very" every time "very" was proposed to be used in a sentence. The result was generally not to use either word, although once in a while a well placed "frigging" did the trick. So, what can we use instead of "world class" to test its meaninglessness in actual application? Anyone? To start you in the right direction, I might propose the following:

    • "curled wass"
    • "class of the world"
    • "world classy"

    It is likely every use of the phrase "world class" could be improved by exchange for "world classy" or at least it's failings would be better understood as a phrase. More to the point, is there any use of "world class" that could not be better stated in some other way?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/21/The_Madness_Of_Not_Doing_What_You_re_Told'

    The Madness Of Not Doing What You're Told

    Posted: December 21st, 2009, 12:50pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Even before that silly rant by Protz last month, it had become more than evident that BrewDog was taking paths not trod in an effort to get the word out about its beer. But all the focus was on their successful abuse of the old guard and those who were satisfied, including financially, with having had it all worked out - and not some of their other approaches:

    ... a group of design and media students from Wrexham's Glyndwr University have won an 'Apprentice' style contest to do just that. Mark Scott, Michelle Roberts, Qingyun Hu, Yz Wez and Phillip Chan had to design the bottle and packaging, pitch the brand and suggest the flavour of a new beer, which will be manufactured by Scottish firm BrewDog, for sale around the university. "We wanted our brand to feel Welsh, have strong associations with the university, and have a catchy name which people could remember to ask for when they'd had a few," explained Phillip Chan, part of the winning '1412' team.

    While a small thing, it's part of the gathering story that BrewDog is not a one trick pony or the advertising gimmick that some would have it. Much has been said, for example, about their reaching out to bloggers but it is not a matter of just sending beers for reviews. Questions are asked and email discussions are held. A decision to be responsive seems to have been included in the marketing plan. I also like the idea that there is a range in price as well. Punk IPA has shown up on Ontario's shelves this month at a very locally modest $2.60 a bottle even as a bottle of Tactical Nuclear Penguin can be delivered to North America for a mere (but, face it, insane) $125.

    Just as there is head scratching that no one thought of grabbing the work "punk" for an IPA and making it their own before - so, too, there must be some chin rubbing over not thinking to ignore convention in all ways to get the word out.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/20/Belgium__Fantome_Noel__Brasserie_Fantome__Soy'

    Belgium: Fantome Noel, Brasserie Fantome, Soy

    Posted: December 20th, 2009, 3:25am CET by Alan McLeod

    I was good to myself. Having a family reunion with one great uncle in the house, I thought I would pop this gem as we consume t-bones and lamb chops. Have you noticed that steaks go discount at Yule? It sure does here. We always have the beef feed in the lead up.

    Barn. Moinette Brune meets Fantome Saison with autumn apple orchard windfall skank. Rich dark fruit on a dry palate. Dark cream foam and rich lacing rim over clouded smoked amber ale. Tang as tangy as a blue cheese as opposed to a vinegared lambic. But more than that, it is like a beer that has gone rusty. The aroma is stunning - gravenstein apple, rising yeast dough, spring time and autumn. Earthy as long as we as speaking about the Earth I want to live on. Happy Christmas to me.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/19/Yule__09_Photo_Contest__I_Plain_Forgot_Three_Prizes'

    Yule '09 Photo Contest: I Plain Forgot Three Prizes

    Posted: December 19th, 2009, 12:46am CET by Alan McLeod

    It is the scatter brained time of year. Why isn't there a mythical nutty character at Christmas time - a Loki or a jester of some sort - that captures that the business of the business of the season makes us do odd things. There ought to be - so pity me and, more to the point, Dave Selden of Portland Oregon who sent me this email this morning:

    Did I miss something, or did you forget to give away 3 copies of 33Beers to a lucky photo winner? I'm happy to save the prize for next year if I'm not sold out. In one of your early posts, you said you'd give them away, but if you've changed your mind, that's okay, too.

    If you haven't heard, 33Beers is a handy dandy beer rating tool that Dave and pals have come up with and sell at a site called 33beers.com. So we need to give three away - like this:

    PictureArtist / ReasonsPrizes
    Troy Burtch of Toronto, Ontario took this photo of an overflowing spile at Cafe Volo's 2009 Cask Days.33Beers VIP package
    Knut Albert Solem of Olso Norway because too often we forget the connection of beer and bike. 33Beers VIP package
    Jason Faulconer of Boston, Mass because that is the view of beer I would have if I were, you know, eleven years old.33Beers VIP package

    Now you will notice that these three last winners are bloggers. Another - Stan - just posted his ideas about what the 33Beer tool can do. Maybe sharing this gift will also mean sharing the discussion of what it can do.

    The last emails will go out this week confirming the prize winners and connecting them with prize givers. I would do it now but I need a nap or a beer. One of those nap or beer moments you need to respect before Christmas to recover from all the running around so you can ensure you are in the right place for naps and beers at Christmas.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/18/A_Good_Beer_Blog_s_Final_Photo_Winners_For_2009'

    A Good Beer Blog's Final Photo Winners For 2009

    Posted: December 18th, 2009, 1:39am CET by Alan McLeod

    So here we are. The last post of the 2010 Good Beer Blog Yuletide Photo Contest and Marital Patience Examination. The entries have been swell and the prize givers have been even sweller - if that is possible. We have had photo entered from across North American and Europe and maybe a few points farther than that. We've had sixteen prize packages so far and are about to give out the last six. Plus, I did not write "shutterbug once" and we have all been the better off because of it.

    The next four generally all equal runner up prizes before the announcement of Grand Loser and the Grand Winner are:

    PictureArtist / ReasonsPrize
    Peter B. Collins, brewer assistant at Grand River Brewing in Cambridge, Ontario for capturing the last day at the cottage A hardcover first edition of Ambitious Brew direct from the author Maureen Ogle.
    Gary Melenhorst the millwright and maintenance guy and John Stephenson the electrician and IT guy from Ontario's Creemore Springs Brewery because they can share it at the brewery and come up with a new wheat beer.The upcoming brand spanking new book on wheat beers also direct from Stan Hieronymus.
    Thomas Cizauskas of Yours for Good Fermentables because I want to be right there and I want to know that guy and be there with him... even if TOM CAN"T COUNT!!! Swag from Creemore Springs including a hockey jersey
    Rob Symes of Toronto, Ontario because - even though that hand pump is unfortunately located - the image of a Japanese salaryman at Popeye's in Tokyo hitting the cask beer after an insanely long work day is both sad and appealing.unsigned copy of Hops and Glory by Pete Brown from me

    Some great entries there with a heavy slant towards Ontario. My bias will not continue as next up is the 2009 Grand Loser as it is such a gloriously bad photo. The winner wrote:

    There's a brewpub under construction in my neighborhood (Migration Brewing), and the do-it-yourself owners have a kegerator in their tunneled-out future pub, to make sure everyone is nourished enough to work. I hope I haven't moved the picture out of last place by putting it into context.

    No worries about that. It is not only in last place but I made up a new award for it and bought the prize myself. Click on what we have below. It is a documentary moment. A dirt pile but an important one.

    PictureArtist / ReasonsPrize
    Bill Night of Portland Oregon and It's Pub Night because that is the ugliest picture I have ever posted on my blog.Unsigned copy of Man walks into a Pub by Pete Brown from me. This is the ugliest cover of a very good book and so is a perfect match for the dirt pile portrait.

    So even though it is the Grand Loser, I hope that the prize is appreciated and received with the thanks with which it is given. Which leaves us the top beer photo submitted for 2009.

    [Drumroll]

    And the Grand Winner of A Good Beer Blog's 2009 Yuletide Photo Contest Is...



    The champion photo every year has spoken to me about the vitality of beer. In the contest's first year of 2006, it was about beer in the state of nature as captured by Dave Selden of Portland Oregon. In 2007, the quiet of the pub was the subject of John Lewington's photo "Two Pints of Bitter" - a candid photo John took of two old boys enjoying their Sunday afternoon ale in a 17th century pub in Aldeburgh, Suffolk. Last year, it was about the labours of the brewer captured in the photo submitted by Matt Wiater of Portland Oregon of Chip Conlon at Roots Organic Brewing.

    This year, the theme is the same - the moment of human interaction with beer - but the moment captured is a new one, the tapping of a cask. Like the other grand prize winners, there is something captured - the light, the moment, the people and the interaction that makes them all partners of a sort. Taken by Kim Reed of Rochester, New York, it shows the second we all wait for, we all day dream of as we play our roles as desk jockey, dairy farmer, coal miner, bank teller. It is the moment beer's work becomes beer's pleasures. For this seeing this moment and placing it an image Kim gets:

    • a signed copy of Hops and Glory from Pete Brown, last week's winner of the UK Beer Writer of the Year 2009;
    • a great Jubelale gift pack from Deschutes Brewing including a Jubelale ornament, Jubelale long-sleeve T-shirt, Jubelale pint glass and a Jubelale poster signed by the artist;
    • a bottle of Yule Tide, the Christmas release tripel from Clipper City; and
    • a year's subscription to All About Beer magazine.

    Kim also sent in four other strong entries which you can see here. All good and all for the goodness of beer photography. Merry Christmas, happy holidays and have a great 2010.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/17/Day_17__Beer_Advent_Calendar___N_Ice_Chouffe'

    Day 17: Beer Advent Calendar - N'Ice Chouffe

    Posted: December 17th, 2009, 1:09pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Jon Abernathy of The Brew Site asked me to join in and place one beer on his Advent calendar this Christmas season. Well, as Jon is I think the only pure beer blogger who may well have been posting longer than I have who am I to say no? I posted my first beer blog post on this stand alone beer blog around Monday 25 October 2004 while his site went back to June. Here is a post from Jon the next day as he finds A Good Beer Blog as he looks throughout an empty internet for other beer blogs. My post was also about hunting out beer sites.

    So Yuletide beer, eh? I wrote about a favorite almost two years ago now and I expect it would be a beer that could warm the heart of even the meanest anti-baby activist:

    Light chestnut-caramel ale under the fine tan rim and foam. Pumpernickel and line scented. In the mouth, this is a really interesting ale with the thyme giving a real roast of lamb effect. A beer that begs to soak a wee sheep's leg as much as a hefeweizen begs to meet pork. Nutty malt with brown sugar richness and a very distinct but balanced thyme presence...pungent even. The coriander is more of a counterpoint, however much it is there in the nose. This beer could match a strong hard cheese well, too, like aged gouda but maybe not anything blue unless it came out of a sheep. Or roast parsnips. It would go with roast parsnips.

    You have no idea how angry it makes me that I don't have a lifetime's store of this beer laid up in the basement - or at lease a deal with Brasserie D'Achouffe that sees two cases show up every December 18th. Life's tragedy summarized right there. Anyway, happy Christmas and a merry New Year to you all.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/17/An_Unexpected_Photo_Contest_Prize_Bonanza'

    An Unexpected Photo Contest Prize Bonanza

    Posted: December 17th, 2009, 1:17am CET by Alan McLeod

    OK... maybe a bonanzette. But still, it was a happy surprise to received two emails today. In one, Jared, a brewer at Harpoon Brewery, confirmed that he had swung a selection of beers from that great Boston beer institution. It is a pick-up sorta gift but there is an opportunity to match beer with boy through the generosity of Harpoon and Jared's hard work.

    In the second, Patrick Morrison, Circulation and Marketing Manager with All About Beer Magazine, wrote to offer a group of prizes and it looks like we have five full year subscriptions to the magazine. One will be added to the pool of prizes for the Grand Winner but we'll place another four in happy and lucky winners' stockings tonight. So, without further adieu, here are six more prizes in the 2009 Good Beer Blog Yuletide Photographic Challenge Royale:

    PictureArtist / ReasonsPrize
    Holly J. M. Haliniewski of Germantown, Maryland for the photo "Last Call at the Englischer Garten" in Munich A Subscription from All About Beer Magazine
    Brian Parker of Audubon, Pennsylvania for sharing this incredible tattoo with the world. A Subscription from All About Beer Magazine
    Ed Gittines of Southbury, Connecticut for having a beer at the greatest place on earth - Fenway Park. A Subscription from All About Beer Magazine
    Scott Grenier of Clinton, New York because not one of you has ever considered the lonliness of the hop bine at dawn... or sunset for that matter. A Subscription from All About Beer Magazine
    Tim Connelly of Cambridge, Massachusetts because I can't get enough photos of Cantillon. I can get enough of their beer (other than gueze) but not photos of the place. Selection of Beers from Harpoon
    Chris Berry of Kanata, Ontario because that baby is freaking me out! copy of The Beer Book from Stan Hieronymus

    That still leaves four more general prizes plus the Grand Loser and, finally, the Grand Prize Winner for 2009.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/16/Ron_s_Food_and_Beer_Christmas_Pairing'

    Ron's Food and Beer Christmas Pairing

    Posted: December 16th, 2009, 1:55pm CET by Alan McLeod

    I love Ron Pattinson's writing. There is something so mid-1700's about it. Vague trembling scientific examinations, untrod paths of first person observations, the search for the ah-ha moment even with the odd reference to the era of A-Ha. And then there are the personal reflections, philosophical essays on the universal truth of the state of man's place in this mortal coil, like today's ruminations on what has been described as "pairing" beer with food, this time at Christmas:

    I don't plan my Christmas drinking as much as stumble into it. Then stumble through it. And end in some type of unconsciousness. Matching beer and food is paramount to my enjoyment of the day. Personally I find St. Bernardus Abt with a Lagavullin on the side matches any meal or snack perfectly. And any mood or time of day. Unfortunately, this year may be different. "Why don't you drink all those beers you have lying about before buying new ones?" Dolores is way too logical. But opposing her isn't a good idea. I still have the scars - both mental and physical - from the last time I tried.

    There, just when we think we are dealing with the early beginnings of the Age of Enlightenment we are suddenly a century later in Dicken's Victorian era of violence, excess and domestic drama. And what food pairings. Everything goes with exactly what is at hand. A true Christmas miracle.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/16/Seven_More_Prizes_And..._Well__Not_Much_More'

    Seven More Prizes And... Well, Not Much More

    Posted: December 16th, 2009, 1:08am CET by Alan McLeod

    I am getting vain about thee tables. I should have tables of something in every post. But what would I put in them. I can't judge photos every day and, franky, it is too hard to do even for just these three nights. This are not necessarily the seventh to twelfth best entries but they are the fourth to seventh awards given. Five more to go and then the Grand Loser and the Grand Winner. We may be able to guess the Grand Loser but there is a decent and appropriate prize coming right from me for that one.

    What do you think of these ones?

    PictureArtist / ReasonsPrize
    Patrick Hirlehey of Waterdown, Ontario provides us with this sharp take on an Ontario annual favorite, Mills Street Vintage Barley Wine. Prize basket from Roland and Russell for a lucky winner in Ontario.
    Scott Mueller of Lawrence, Kansas for robot beer and baby. Tee-shirt from craftbeerclothing.com
    Zak Rotello of the Olympic Tavern in Rockford, Illinois of a funky bung stopper on an active lambic barrel at Cantillon. unsigned copy of Hops and Glory by Pete Brown from me
    Lars Marius Garshol of Oslo, Norway for one of the few pub shops submitted. I think this is the Jerusalem in London, England. Tavern Tee-shirt from Maine's Shipyard
    Gregg Wiggins of Arlington, Virginia for seeing the opportunity in a fridge. Tee-shirt from craftbeerclothing.com
    Nate Howe of Lausanne, Switzerland because he got both the snow and the backlit glow of the beer. Tee-shirt from Maine's Shipyard
    Jeremy Craigs of North York, Ontario for capturing the futuristic moment at a brewery. The one year subscription to TAPS magazine, Canada's beer quarterly.

    See you tomorrow.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/15/Three_Prizes_Announced__Two_UK_Plus_One_German'

    Three Prizes Announced: Two UK Plus One German

    Posted: December 15th, 2009, 3:21am CET by Alan McLeod

    Announcing three prizes tonight because I am still trying to make sure the table works and, if you must know, the Olympic torch came through town this evening. It was cool and cheesy, earnest and corporate all at the same time. Maybe like this annual photo contest.

    First, however, a big shout out first to reader Jen in Florida aka blogster Scurrilous Tosh who offered to fix me up a HTML table by both comment and email. I hope I did you proud, global HTML friendship ambassador.

    Next, the disclaimer. I try really hard to pick prize givers who I think will honour their pledges and these two are among the best. Tami at Shipyard and James at BrewDog have been big supporters of this here blog as well as others who share the dream - or at least, you know, dream a little dream of beer. But if there is a blip, a delay, a snafu or a screw up - well - at that point it's like a 1970s UK sci-fi show and I am the face on the little wrist watch screen on the arm of the astronaut whose cord has been cut during a spacewalk that shouts "I can't reach you, Larry! I can't see you!!! Laaaaarrrrryyy!!!" By this I mean, if the mail fails or the prize giver fails or stuff happens, you can email me and I will pester and most pestering works. But one prize might not be under a tree.

    One. Elf. Cries.

    But enough of the disclaimer. We are here to give and studies have shown that well over 96% of prizes from A Good Beer Blog annual Yuletide, Xmas, Kwanza, Hanukkah, Festivus and Hogmanay Photo Contest do make it through. They do. They do. They do.... So, here are the first three prizes.

    PictureArtist / ReasonsPrizeGiven By
    Robert Gale, Torfaen, Wales because there were two UK entries and two UK-only prizes and these were good. One mixed case of BrewDog beer BrewDog
    Scotland
    John H Lewington of Suffolk, England because there were two UK entries and two UK-only prizes, former grand prize winner and, heck, why not. Serves the rest of the UK right. One mixed case of BrewDog beer BrewDog
    Scotland
    Barry Masterson, Muenster, Germany because of the expressions. One Awesome T-shirt! Shipyard Brewing
    Portland, Maine

    More tomorrow. Can't wait.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/13/Perhaps_Think_Of_Beers_For_Giving_Not_Receiving'

    Perhaps Think Of Beers For Giving Not Receiving

    Posted: December 13th, 2009, 6:36pm CET by Alan McLeod

    There are lot of I want, I want, I want lists going around, however well intentioned, but it strikes me that the whole point at this time of year is you placing goods and services in the hands of others. It's in fact the most transactional time of the year - which means, as Mr. B. reminds us, the gifting goes in both directions. So, while we all know our own appetites and avaricious desires when it comes to all things beery, surely there are some suggestions for giving beer that can be established:

    • Do not let Christmas lead to remorse. Guard your stash with your life. Don't tell your house guests where it actually can be found and be careful when dipping in yourself. Nothing kills a party more than the challenging surprise of a case of bone dry geuze foisted upon the uninitiated. And you will feel unwell if you catch it being secretly poured down the sink or even sneered upon.
    • Conversely, don't be a scrooge. There is a reason we have Christmas beers and winter ales - not to mention dubbels which will do in a pinch. They are the gateway drug for all strong beer. Even barley wine can lead a novice wondering why but add a few spices and some Belgian yeast and, whammo, we are all happy again. I stockpile these for my own holiday cheer and, frankly, it would do me and you good to share given the punch they pack.
    • This is a good time to move some flavoured beer. Right now in my neck of the woods there is a good supply of Southern Tier Creme Brulee. At 10% and packed with real vanilla pod scrapings, it is unctuous and quickly filling. But it would also go well poured over steam pudding or next to a trifle. Same with sweet lambics, the umbrella in the coconut of the good beer world. Face facts: people like dessert so people will like trying a little new sweet flavoured beer.
    • Finally, lay in something closer to what your guests drink than you do. No one really likes the missionary's zeal even at this holy time of year. It is a time of giving and what you can give all your friends and family is a break from your insane hobby interest in the obscure and the difficult.

    There you go. Mull some beer for the family, give a mixed six of Belgians to a co-worker. Give but give wisely and wisdom tells us that not all are fascinated by beer to the degree or in the way that you are. So, save that real geuze for your own New Year's Eve. You know you and your guests want you to. Any hints of your own?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/13/Day_27__The_Contest_Closes_With_These_Final_Entries'

    Day 27: The Contest Closes With These Final Entries

    Posted: December 13th, 2009, 1:08am CET by Alan McLeod

    Well, that was fun. The fourth annual 2009 Good Beer Blog Yuletide, Xmas, Kwanza, Hanukkah, Festivus and Hogmanay Photo Contest closed two hours ago and once I post these ten last entrant's selections, well, then I get to pick the winners. I am going to take a couple of days to review the photos, pick the winners and then announce them all at one time. As a preliminary observation, plenty of beer and snow. And little or no beer and a plate of food. Well done. On my count we have had 45 entrants who submitted a total of 185 photos. There was a drop in UK participants due to me not partnering with Jeffo of the Gunmakers. So we had 45 participants in 2009 compared to 70 beer pornographers in 2008. But the five picture rule made my life sane by reducing the total I had to save and post from the 524 I had to deal with last year. And sane is good.

    On to the last wave of entries. First up, Stan Hieronymus of New Mexico, USA has sent in these five including one that immediately challenges the eye as to what beer is.

    Next, Jared Kiraly of Cambridge, Mass. and a brewer with Harpoon sent in these photos from the inner sanctum of the brewery.

    Troy Burtch of Toronto, Ontario and the blog Great Canadian Pubs and Beer as well as the prize giving TAPS magazine sent in these five:

    Next, Kim Reed of that great beer city Rochester, NY sent in these five excellent shots including one of the best I have ever seen of a keg being tapped.

    Moving right along, Holly J. M. Haliniewski of Germantown, Maryland sent in six pictures but explained she is "a long time reader (lurker) of your blog and after three years of watching the photo contest go by I decided to send in my 5 entries this time!" - meaning that there are counting issues. But as the photos cover trips to Germany, New Zealand as well as a holiday in Cambodia, well, what the heck:


    Getting close to the wire, Mike Contasti-Isaac of Peterborough, Ontario got these entries in with 41 minutes to go before the contest closed:

    Starting to push his luck, Robert Gale of Torfaen, Wales sent in these five solid entries with only 35 minutes to go. He also mentioned that he likes BrewDog and "and I've got a few bottles of their latest beer, Tactical Nuclear Penguin to try." A few bottles?!?! I think all of Canada only got a few bottles of this one. The last of the set is from an old pub in Newport, Wales that dates from 1530:

    Finally, the last submission today came in with 18 minutes to go from John Kleinchester of Brooklyn, NY and, ominously for the rest of the participants, from the website beertography.com.

    But we are not done as I missed two. These were sent in earlier but needed cleaning up. First, Ashok Argent-Katwala recently of London England but now of Toronto sent in these two portraits of a bottle of JackD'or by Pretty Things. I have a bottle of this in the stash and plan to pop it over the holidays:

    Last and certainly not least, we have Robert Curran of generous prize giving Ontario's Creemore Springs Brewery who has forwarded five pictures by Gary Melenhorst the millwright and maintenance guy and John Stephenson the electrician and IT guy. They went on a tear through Germany this summer. They took in Klosterbrau Ettal, which is a Benedictine Kloster. Hofbrau Berchtesgadener. Berchtesgadener is located near to the Obersalzberg and the Eagles Nest. They did indeed find themselves at the top of the Eagles Nest. They also visited Schloss Linderhof, which was Ludwig's hunting lodge [not too shabby]. They managed a visit to Weihenstephan and Schneider Weiss, and Klosterbrau Weltenburg as well, too many other breweries to mention. Rob has gleaned these ten pictures out of a total of over 500 Gary and John took.


    That is it! Let the ruminations begin. I don't even know how many prizes we have to give out but I don't have one for everyone.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/12/Day_27__The_2009_Yule_Photo_Contest_Extravaganza_Ends_Today'

    Day 27: The 2009 Yule Photo Contest Extravaganza Ends Today

    Posted: December 12th, 2009, 9:45pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Still an hour and 16 minutes left to enter. Lurkers Holly and Robert entered in the last 15 minutes. You can, too.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/12/Day_26__The_Day_Before_The_Day_It_All_Ends_This_Yule'

    Day 26: The Day Before The Day It All Ends This Yule

    Posted: December 12th, 2009, 1:36am CET by Alan McLeod

    It has been a placid time this Yule so far. The plan for the beer blog contest being less onerous has worked out very nicely. I know that because my wife tells me so. Thanks for your understanding as I know there is a lot of interest in the goofy idea of me making people I have never met send free stuff to people, well, that I have never met. So with less than 24 hours to go, I give you the prize and photo submission updates.

    More Prizes. Stan has offered a copy of The Beer Book edited by Tim Hampson which has a section on US beer written by Stan. Tami, my correspondent from Shipyard in Portland, Maine has offered three t-shirts celebrating their Pugsley’s Signature Series shown to the right. Let me check the email. There may be more.

    We go around the world with today's photo updates. John Lewington of Suffolk, England sent another entry to the left taken on the Spanish island of Tenerife and Hunter Williams of Shanghai in China forwarded the photo to the right taken at Windsor in England.

    And Knut Albert Solem of Oslo, Norway of Knut Albert's Beer Blog fame forwarded three photos below of his recent trip to London, England. You know, you people really get around.

    Mike Nereng of no fixed address, Planet Earth sent this one photo of a rather surprised spouse at Hofbräuhaus - which I take to be the one in Munich and not the one in Edmonton, Alberta. Adam Reinke of Arden, North Carolina provided this photo of Bud on ice with this story: "While traveling for business, as I returned to my hotel room after a meeting, I met the room service staff delivering a guest a beer. The presentation of the Budweiser sitting in ice like a fine bottle of champagne was a photo opportunity I could not pass up."

    And Mark Michalsk of Owings Mills, Maryland sent in these five pics. I think took the hint about beer and snow very literally. I don't think that is necessariily a bad thing but...

    Brian Parker of Audubon, Pennsylvania and the blog I am Beer Wise sent in these five photos including one displaying a true dedication to the great beers of Stone:

    Jeremy Craigs of North York, Ontario sent in these five including one that looks like its from a set of a 1970s sci-fi TV show going cheap on the sets.

    That is all for now. There are more in the cue and you still have time to take and forward that magic moment between boy and beer or girl and glass. Keep them coming.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/11/Book_Review__World_s_Best_Beers_By_Ben_McFarland'

    Book Review: World's Best Beers By Ben McFarland

    Posted: December 11th, 2009, 3:50am CET by Alan McLeod

    Cole Porter laid it out for us all. The mathematics of what is "top" proves is a very difficult thing to determine. Whether you say "top" or "leading" or "foremost" or "best" it is all the same. You are not saying much. Consider that Cole Porter's equation inherent in the lyrics of You're The Top is essentially the equation "top = X where X = ???" If your math is weak consider the text itself:

    You're the top!
    You're the Coliseum.
    You're the top!
    You're the Louver Museum.
    You're a melody from a symphony by Strauss
    You're a Bendel bonnet,
    A Shakespeare's sonnet,
    You're Mickey Mouse.
    You're the Nile,
    You're the Tower of Pisa,
    You're the smile on the Mona Lisa
    I'm a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop,
    But if, baby, I'm the bottom you're the top!

    And that's just the first verse. What you can see from both Porter's arithmetic as well as his poetry is that the meaning of a superlative form of good is an utter quagmire. For example, what the hell is a Bendel bonnet? Who knows? Who cares? It has become decontextualized by the passage of time so that even if I bothered to ask Lord Goog what it was, it would not explain what the reference meant to Cole Porter.

    And it is with that knowledge that I have approached Ben McFarland's beer book World's Best Beers: One Thousand Craft Brews From Cask To Glass. But first things first. I come not to bury McFarland but to praise him. This is a great book and in part not only because it is a huge list but because it is a number of lists. A lot of lists in fact.

    • It is a list of the great beer regions of the world. That is the primary organization of the book, as an atlas.
    • It also contains a list of great beers found within each region. It does not contain a list of #1 to #1,000. So while I can say I am about to open a bottle of third down right side, page 191, I can't say that I am opening a bottle of #537.
    • It also contains a list of great beer writers in that McFarland does not write each region's list but outsources many of them to writers like Stephen Beaumont and Lew Bryson. And there are even new names to me like Bryan Harrell in Japan.
    • But, more as gazetteer than atlas, it also has other lists - like the beers and foods that Garrett Oliver likes to consumer concurrently; like the top ten beer drinking cities; and even like the top ten iconic beer packagings.
    • And there is even a list of beer sites you need to following... including (big girlie thrill) this very one right there on page 274.

    Lists of lists. It is an approach to beer. One avenue to beer and it is an avenue McFarland explores thoroughly. Sufficiently even. I don't think I needed another list. I know Stan doesn't. Stan is against lists these days but he took the time to think about how even he might list beer. So we might at this point summarize as follow: Ben likes lists, Stan doesn't and Cole Porter thought them an outlet more for his wit than as a means to achieve any precise definition.

    Mr. Beaumont has also been listing this week but his is a list of aphorisms - so while he calls them his "Beer Rules for the Holidays" it is more a code or codex even, like the Old Testament's Book of Proverbs. Indeed, he takes a stand that is rather mad minor prophet raging against the howling wind with staff in hand, telling us more what not to do that do with wise lessons like "Pay Up or Shut Up" and "At a Social Gathering, You Are Expressly Prohibited From Saying, 'This Pale Ale Isn’t Very Hoppy, Is It?'" Why do I mention this in a book review of the work of someone else? Well, I think it illustrates that the way to good beer has many paths and so while Stan rightly dislikes lists and while Ben rightly likes them - one can also find good beer's righteousness proverbially as Mr. B does or also rightly through detailed gleaning through brewing records like Ron Pattinson or as Knut, the beer ticking traveling Norwegian, does... rightly. There is a place at the table for every sect and denomination. It is right that it is so.

    Point? There is a world of great beer and it is enjoyed by the world. There are many ways of good beer. And even if there is no best way, each and every worthy route and every worthy form of analysis is a path to knowing more about good beer. McFarland's book is one such path and beats the hell out of the list as a medium for describing what good beer can be. And he does it very well.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/10/One_Way_To_Not_Promote_Craft_Beer_All_That_Well'

    One Way To Not Promote Craft Beer All That Well

    Posted: December 10th, 2009, 3:16am CET by Alan McLeod

    I was pleased to see Canada's other national newspaper, The National Post, feature some information about craft breweries in Ontario but was a bit saddened to see the odd approach that was chosen - five generic questions leading to an opportunity to trigger five Pavlovian advertising copy responses. Consider this one exchange:

    Q: Describe your facilities.
    A: Wellington Brewery is noted for its distinctive exterior appearance with the look of a traditional hop roast house and hop vines. At 7,200 square feet, the brewery has a hospitality room available to the public, retail store and a production facility, housing its traditional English infusion mash tun and direct fire brewhouse, as well as it's state of the art canning line.

    I don't know why the description of the facilities is a question that represents 20% of the "best possible questions to trigger interesting information about the subject" that one might hope is a part of a journalist's skill set. But I did learn that hops are roasted and that this is one of the two traditions celebrated in the architecture. Key to attracting me as a craft beer buyer is, after all, the architecture. Other gems gleaned using up another 20% of the allotted Q+A time include that their "brewing philosophy is to use the finest ingredients available and to strike a careful balance with the malts and hops" and that their "business philosophy is service, service, service to our over 700 customers throughout Ontario." Now, call me old fashioned but if a brewery says it is the oldest in Canada, soon to be celebrating its 25th anniversary and I, the potential customer, learn it only has 700 customers in a province of over 13 million souls? Well, you can fill in the rest.

    How did such a thing happen? How did hop drying become hop roasting? How do (what one hopes) 700 successful bar accounts come off sounding like 700 measly consumers? How does this opportunity get lost?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/09/Day_23__Only_A_Few_Days_To_Go_But_More_Pics_Daily'

    Day 23: Only A Few Days To Go But More Pics Daily

    Posted: December 9th, 2009, 1:26am CET by Alan McLeod

    This bit above is a detail from a picture received today from Germany. What to call it? "I Wish I Had A Cell Phone, Too" or maybe "I Really Should Leave These Two Alone"? Sums it all up really, this 21st century. Click for a larger revelation of the facial expression. I wish I had a yellow tie.

    Now, more entries. For starters, John H Lewington fo somewhere in England and winner of the 2007 grand prize offers this one photo to the right and takes the lead in the so far one man BrewDog beer race for best UK entry. In other Euro-land news, Barry Masterson of Muenster, Germany provides us with these views below - including one of maybe the same bottles I think we saw from Joe Stange in 2008:

    Mike Stich of Toronto has forwarded these entries:

    Timothy Cox of Hampton New Brunswick offered these photos up:

    Keep them coming...

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/08/Day_22__Wherein_We_Get_A_Photo_Contest_Update'

    Day 22: Wherein We Get A Photo Contest Update

    Posted: December 8th, 2009, 2:45am CET by Alan McLeod

    Let's start with an entry. An entry from another man who cannot count. Thomas Cizauskas of Yours for Good Fermentables sent in six pictures with the message "one, two, three, four, six" which just goes to show you. It really does. I like them and I like Tom so six it is. One's up top there and here are the rest. Hey ain't getting an extra prize, though:

    There are more entries down below and more in the cue still but let's catch up on on the prizes. It has been a bit nuts lately but, thankfully, I seem to not have to really drum up prizes as the pledges are coming through the email nicely on their own. Here is what we have so far:

    • A one year subscription to TAPS magazine, Canada's beer quarterly.
    • A hardcover first edition of Ambitious Brew direct from the author Maureen Ogle.
    • the upcoming brand spanking new book on wheat beers also direct from Stan Hieronymus,
    • a prize basket from Roland and Russell for a lucky winner in Ontario
    • a group of prizes from Maine's Shipyard which I will further define.
    • beer from BrewDog which can only be won in the UK. But we have no UK entries so it may go begging,
    • a signed copy of Hops and Glory from Pete Brown, last week's winner of the UK Beer Writer of the Year 2009, as well as a few unsigned copies of his books,
    • a bottle of Yule Tide, the Christmas release tripel from Clipper City
    • two shirt from craftbeerclothing.com which also offers a 15% discount to beer blog readers who use the a special coupon code called "holidaybeer",
    • some swag from Creemore Springs including a hockey jersey in it, a "prairie shirt" as well as a hat or some glassware depending on distance to be shipped.
    • and last but not least a great gift pack from Deschutes Brewing The gift pack includes a Jubelale ornament, Jubelale long-sleeve T-shirt, Jubelale pint glass and a Jubelale poster signed by the artist

    Wow. And I get none of it. That is the problem. I should just do all this for me, me, me. But that would not be nice at Yule. Summertime? Watch out for the man in the mirror, that's all I am saying. Entries next. Andrew Bartle of Toronto Ontario sent some verse ("The eyes of the beholder/Just the tip of the iceberg/nothing wrong with a scuffy glass/it's enough to see) and got all experimental with his entries:

    Nate of no last name and no postal address but of the blog Bier Adventures sent these five. Notice his attention to one requirement for Yuletide photo context mastery, snow:

    That is it for now. Still days to go before I rest. Keep them coming...

    Information UpNate: Got the skinny on our entrant Nate - he is Nate Howe of Lausanne, Switzerland. Who knew?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/06/Day_21__Prize_Buying_With_One_Week_To_Go'

    Day 21: Prize Buying With One Week To Go

    Posted: December 6th, 2009, 2:33pm CET by Alan McLeod

    I was checking out Amazon to see what beer books I missed this year. Huge sale on so, being the canny Yuletide 2009 beer photo context administrator I am, I picked up a few extra copies on the cheap of Pete Brown's books for you US readers who have been frozen out by some insane publishers who refuse to place it into your bookstores. Never fear. Canada is here. Entries are getting backed up and I don't know if I have enough to give away. Remember to get your entries in this week as next week is too late. Contest closes 12 December. Rules: 5 photos (unless you can't count), no flash photos of beer next to a plate of food, snow shots get a bonus, remember to include your postal address. I think those are all the rules. Oh, and not 19,476 KB photos. I don't like spending my evenings reducing the scale of digital photos on a 2003 era computer. You can hear the cogs creaking when I do.

    Also, heading off into the northern reaches of upstate New York today for Christmas shopping and hopefully a dip into Bessette's stock in Canton NY. Taking a six of McAuslan oatmeal stout as a gift for the hosts of the NCPR volunteer Christmas party - I answer volunteer phones in another country. Who ever thought it would come to that? More later.

    Update post haul: Got the tiniest lecturette at Canada Customs, the guard eager to point out that half my taxes and duties were "due to that beer" - like I ought to know better, like I shouldn't. Too bad he was unaware that $4.99 a bomber for Stone is pretty sweet as is $5.99 for Sly Fox Route 113 IPA so far from home. The larder is well padded now. Found one six of Troeg's porter just sitting there, 17 miles from the Canadian border. Other stuff as well. I am giddy as a schoolgirl. Well, maybe as a 46 year old who is totally Dad.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/05/Session_34__The_Wobbly_Road_Home'

    Session 34: The Wobbly Road Home

    Posted: December 5th, 2009, 2:29am CET by Alan McLeod

    I have to say that the topic "Stumbling Home" is hardly inspirational as it has nothing to do with craft beer - but as I have posted a post for every edition of The Session, well, I didn't want to break my streak.

    The real reason, however, is that I have a little something in the can on this one, the story of a pal who made it home alive after falling asleep in the snow. It was over 20 years ago and it was in Halifax, Nova Scotia. And he was saved by the donair wrapped in foil he had tucked in his jacket over his heart. True story. In celebration of his salvation by savory snack, years later we held a small poetry contest recalling the event:

    #1

    Dark. Snow. Ale fun hours.
    Young man prone, alone, drift-hid,
    Blood thanks meaty warmth.

    #2

    Just a cone wrapped up in foil,
    Oozing whitish sauce and oil,
    Gave the world one doctor's toil.
    Fate's foe played a spicy foil!

    #3

    Look...there, quite by the fence,
    Dark, laying in the drift:
    Too full of Keiths his head to lift.
    Not near the home he rents -
    Heedless now of consequence

    The snowfall lays upon his head

    And gathers by his arm.
    Jon is slipping nearer harm
    and a frosty final bed!
    How can Jon not be dead?

    Ah...one small patch...the snow melts there.
    Above his chest of sweaty hair,
    Upon his heart, the guardian fare,
    Within his coat, a large donair.

    #4

    Snow stings my forehead.
    My footprints slowly fill in.
    The taste of last night's donair.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/04/Pete_s_The_Man___More_Later_With_Video'

    Pete's The Man - More Later With Video

    Posted: December 4th, 2009, 3:55am CET by Alan McLeod

    If I could do an ABC Wide World of Sports 1970s video retrospective on the man's career to date I would. Brown wins! Pete Brown wins!!!

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/04/Joints__Collaboration_Not_Litigation__Avery___Russian_River'

    Joints: Collaboration Not Litigation, Avery / Russian River

    Posted: December 4th, 2009, 1:45am CET by Alan McLeod

    What to call these beers? For the last few years, brewers have been getting together to make something new together. This one has a deeper back story than most but the point is the same. In the end they are joint projects, opportunities to get together, to share and learn. And no doubt to have a lot of fun. But what do they offer us, the consumer? They are the specials of the specials. The seasonals with only one season. Yet surely they have to stand up for themselves as beer and not be the wall hanging commemorative china plate of the beer world. What can I learn from just this bottle?

    Blended three years ago, it pours a lovely light cola colour with a frothy deep cream head. The aroma (aka smell) is dandy - date and sharp apple.with a floral thing that is almost rose. On the sip and swish, there is plenty of rich pumpernickel malt but with that Avery drying hard water. Dark chocolate, dark plum and a nod to cinnamon with an interesting juiciness that nods to pear or white grape. It is styled as a Belgian strong dark ale and that makes sense. Yet there is an the underlying tone. The hard water for me is not working but that is a personal thing for me that I have noticed since I tried a line up from Colorado's Great Divide. I am a soft water man. Yet there is a rich plum dark sugar finish. Solid if, for me, slightly sub-moreish.

    Plenty o' BAer respect. Take their advice.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/03/Thanks_To_Our_Google_Reader_Subscribers'

    Thanks To Our Google Reader Subscribers

    Posted: December 3rd, 2009, 12:59am CET by Alan McLeod

    Nothing deep or profound this evening. Just a thanks to the readers and, tonight, especially those on Google Reader. After six years of beer blogging, it has become harder to figure out how many people actually follow a blog given those followers on various aggregating services. But one, Google Reader, hit 5,000 followers recently. 5,011 today. I think I'm also glad that you are not all sending in photos to the beer blog Xmas photo contest. Thanks for that, too.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/02/Day_16__Stonch_a_tross_Forsaken..._And_Pics'

    Day 16: Stonch-a-tross Forsaken... And Pics

    Posted: December 2nd, 2009, 1:00am CET by Alan McLeod

    This 2009 Yuletide Beer Photo Extravaganza and Gift-a-thon is a little different. It's a little quieter than recent years. It's a little lonely. I was wondering why that was so I wrote a poem to express myself in the style of a certain salty 1800s epic:

    The Rime of the Ancient Beer Blogger

    There was an ancient beer blogger,
    With contests one, two, three.
    "By thy coffee cup and dressing gown,
    Now wherefore stopp'st thou me ?

    The Gunmaker's doors are opened wide,
    And I am going in;
    My friends are met, the feast is set:
    May'st hear the merry din."

    He holds him with his pudgy hand,
    "There was a contest..." quoth he.
    "Hold off ! unhand me, blogging fool !"
    Eftsoons a tale dropt he...

    [An interjection here to shortcut and avoid 53 more stanzas about the smelly old beer blogger outside The Gunmaker's Pub. Seems that there was a blog of good omen that brought luck to beer bloggers which was treated unspeakably ...]

    ...On trips to Rome, or brew at home;
    This blogger we did follow,
    And every day, for food or play,
    Came to the ancient's hollo !

    In London's mist, in tavern loud,
    He perched the barstool fine;
    Whiles all the night with cask ale bright,
    And drank the white Moon-shine."

    "God save thee, ancient beer blogger!
    From the fiends, that plague thee thus !--
    Thou look'st so lost?' "...He mumbled out:
    "I forsook Stonch, such great loss!!!"

    There! The poetic arts have been the balm that have brought it all into view, made it all so clear. See, when I decided to slim down the photo contest, I figured Jeff was far too busy to even be bothered. But lo and behold, we have not had a single entry from the UK so far and only two from outside of North America. And we have one UK-only prize, two boxes of assorted BrewDog. This is what vanity leads to, you know. This is what you get for rushing. Make me think of another poem...

    No beer blogger is an Island...

    But, on second thought, I'll save that one for another day. Here are more entries in the photo contest. Ed Gittines of Southbury, Connecticut sends in these five including a very good view at Fenway Park:

    Scott Grenier of Clinton, NY sent these three photos of hops from an abandoned 1860's hop farm here in Central New York. He says the hops are an old variety of Cluster and are pretty tasty in an English style bitter or brown ale but that they can have a pretty intense grapefruit flavor when the beer is young.

    I got this further update from Scott in an email just now:

    Each fall I harvest around 3lbs of hops from the property, dry them, and brew with them a few times a year. Historically, the hops grown here were English Cluster and the ones I harvest are essentially the same variety, but have gone feral. I have brewed a number of beers with these hops, including a brown ale that I brewed according to a 1870's recipe from the Oneida Brewery? (Utica) that used hops grown from this area. I am pretty sure it is the first time someone had used these hops to brew a beer in around 140 years - And the beer tastes great! It is pretty amazing how much beer history is located here in CNY - though most people have no idea. All around this area you can find old hop barns, kilns, and hedgerows full of hops waiting to be picked.

    Prizes? So far we are looking at the new book from Stan Hieronymus, a prize basket from Roland and Russell, stuff from Shipyard, beer from BrewDog, the new book from Pete Brown, a tripel from Clipper City, a shirt from craftbeerclothing.com, some swag from Creemore Springs and a not yet defined something from Deschutes Brewing. Great stuff... yet I need to work on more prizes. I know it. You know it.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/12/01/Day_15__War__Xmas_Photos_And_Roger_Freaks_Out_'

    Day 15: War, Xmas Photos And Roger Freaks Out!

    Posted: December 1st, 2009, 12:54am CET by Alan McLeod

    I got a great gift in the mail today. Copy 8 of 10 of Ron Pattinson's new book, WAR! He wrote about the book's release this very morning from his home in The Netherlands and by suppertime a copy was in my mailbox here in Canada. Compiling his studies to date on the years of World War I and World War II, it is a great example of the work he is doing to bringing actual detailed primary research to the question of the history of beer.

    One wishes all beer writers were so concerned with the facts as we witnessed today from Roger Protz who went all freaky handbags over BrewDog's new and insanely strong beer. He's received a number of head shaking responses, deservedly so given his use of language like "over-inflated egos and naked ambition" and "the wild buckeroos" and "what were you smoking last night, chaps?" and "this bunch of ego-maniacs" and "anxious to give beer a bad name." The oddest thing is that he goes off on his own ice flow all the while misunderstanding the technical process used for actually making the beer, baldly claiming it had wine yeast in it... not that wine yeast would get you a 32% beer. One wonders what Protz was thinking or, in fact, had been smoking himself when he wrote such a blurt. He has certainly gone a long way to discredit his own opinions on experimental beer generally. For a more measured response, you may want to read Pete Brown's post on the new and insanely strong beer from last Thursday...you know, when it was news.

    Now with the Xmas 2009 Beer Blog Yuletide Photo Contest Extravaganza. First, a couple of solo entries from Canada.

    Chris Berry of Kanata, Ontario sent this one picture to the left which sorta looks normal... until you have a good look at the baby's face. Frank MacDonald of Torbay Newfoundland kept the kids out of the photo to the right. It was taken at the Grizzly Paw Brewpub in Canmore Alberta.

    Next, Jeff Alworth of Portland, Oregon has sent in some photos from the scene there. I have no idea how he got to put in 8 entries but never having been to Oregon I can't be sure this is not some sort of cultural thing, some sort of secret message to us all. Maybe he can't count. Better not mess with the photo set just in case:


    Finally Tim Connelly of Cambridge Massachusetts sent in these pictures which are entitled "Inside Cantillon," "In a Galway pub," "Outside of a Galway pub," "The Franciscan Well Brewery Pub, Cork' and "Brooklyn Brewery":

    Four more great entries. I better starting beating the bush for more prizes. Here I go. Off to email brewers until all I have are bloody stumps for hands. Why? I don't do it for you. I do it for Santa.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/11/29/Do_The_Principles_Of__The_Moon_Under_Water__Hold_'

    Do The Principles Of "The Moon Under Water" Hold?

    Posted: November 29th, 2009, 3:42pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Nothing like nicking an idea from a smarter beer blogger. Pete Brown has waxed about George Orwell by way of introduction to his post about that beer movie called Beertickers: Beyond The Ale. While the movie is likely to be recognized as the best beer movie of the year, Pete's comments about it are not what I am nicking. It's an essay of Orwell's he mentions, "The Moon Under Water." You can find the whole text here but as it is so short I will ruin it for you by sharing the end:

    ...if anyone knows of a pub that has draught stout, open fires, cheap meals, a garden, motherly barmaids and no radio, I should be glad to hear of it, even though its name were something as prosaic as the Red Lion or the Railway Arms.

    In that conclusion, Orwell provides a summary of his argument as any good rhetorician would. Somewhere I read that a good presentation begins with an explanation of what you are about to say, a description of the five points to be made, the making of the five points, a description that you just heard about five points and, finally, an explanation of what you just said. Orwell is far better than the lunkiness of that scheme but essentially uses that sort of structure. And he does so to the end of defining the perfect pub. For our purposes, note the description of the food:

    You cannot get dinner at the Moon Under Water, but there is always the snack counter where you can get liver-sausage sandwiches, mussels (a speciality of the house), cheese, pickles and those large biscuits with caraway seeds in them which only seem to exist in public-houses. Upstairs, six days a week, you can get a good, solid lunch —for example, a cut off the joint, two vegetables and boiled jam roll—for about three shillings.

    Note the modesty and implied value that the pub brings. Good food for a reasonable price. Sandwich as snack. He even uses the word "cheap" - imagine! And while he doesn't "pair" let alone "tick" you do have a sense that the creamy stout goes well with the cut off the joint. All part of the refuge that is offered by "The Moon Under Water" - comfort. I am not sure I have ever known a complete copy but have to admit that there is a garden or at least a courtyard at the Kingston Brew Pub, the family friendly pub with a solid oatmeal stout that both encouraged and justifies our thousand mile move to this town. But they have no china beer mugs. Now all I want in life is a china beer mug. Not another stein. Not pottery - actual china.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/11/28/Day_13__Xmas_Photos_Of_Beer_Are_Still_Arriving'

    Day 13: Xmas Photos Of Beer Are Still Arriving

    Posted: November 28th, 2009, 8:04pm CET by Alan McLeod

    I am a little less than pleased with the idea of Xmas beer today. I did the math and realized that one bottle out of the six - usually a sensible session - overwhelmed the others, sneaking an extra 38% of strength into the evening. Oh, for a session beer culture. Not sorry headed or anything but who really needs to be bagged on a Saturday over a Friday night six pack? The inhumanity of it all. Anyway, enough about me. Here are two more entrants.

    Jason Faulconer of Boston, Mass - keeper of the blog Brewing the Perfect Beer - has sent these two entries from a recent trip to San Francisco's Magnolia's Pub and Brewery:

    Peter B. Collins, brewer assistant at Grand River Brewing in Cambridge, Ontario as sent in these five including a few from the brewery:

    All very snazzy with both displaying control in the all important focal depth... thing.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/11/28/How_Better_To_Celebrate_A_Church_s_750th_Anniversary_'

    How Better To Celebrate A Church's 750th Anniversary?

    Posted: November 28th, 2009, 12:15am CET by Alan McLeod

    The heart cheers at the appropriateness of this news:

    The service, which begins at 7.30pm, will reflect on the church's past, celebrate its present role and look to the next 750 years. The church choir will be joined by choirs from other local churches at this communion service. After the service, there will be refreshments available including a beer, The Bronescombe Ale, brewed for the occasion by O'Hanlon's Brewery, Whimple. The beer has been named after Bishop Walter Bronescombe who, on the feast of St Andrew in 1259, arrived in Ottery St Mary and dedicated the Church of Sancte Marie de Otery.

    There are so many words in the language that have faded from use which, like bridal, reflect a past connection between the Church and the cask. Church ales they were called. Bloggers who are much clever that I am have the details in these things. In this case, we can rely on this post by Martyn the Zythophile entitled "Ale, Churches and Brides"... but I am not sure even he knows the name for a church ale celebrating a 750th.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/11/26/Day_10__Even_More_On_Innovation_And__Yes__More_Photos'

    Day 10: Even More On Innovation And, Yes, More Photos

    Posted: November 26th, 2009, 1:26am CET by Alan McLeod

    It was a day of reading about new things in beer. Not just new new things but things that introduce newness in beer. And not just experimentation either:

    • Lew was not struck dumb about the new porter from Narragansett. Uncle Jack has mentioned Lew's capacity to "wax poetic about virtually every single thing he did" but I think Lew is truly on to something - a lower price knockout of a porter. If not utterly new, well, then it is a welcome trend. And my type of innovation.
    • Like the rest of the beer blogging world did or had in mind, I made fun of the launch of Molson M, the world’s only “Microcarbonated” lager beer. Stan's wit was dry but look down in the comments. It seems some are wondering if they may actually be on to something that makes a real difference: "if they have developed something that can force carbonate without creating nucleation sites that volatilize the hop aroma, more power to them."
    • Stephen B. moves away from what is in the bottle like great budget porter or tiny bubbles and illustrates innovation with Stone's Vertical Epic series. The project will last 17 days under 12 full years to complete. I have three of the nine released so far and will probably keep them until 12 12 12 as there will no doubt be some party worth opening them at. The only additional point I would make is that it is also a program with budget in mind. Stone has released instructions on how to make a home brew clone for each year's chapter in the epic tale. This is in addition to the fact that the bombers retail for well under ten bucks each. Again, innovation need not bankrupt you.

    Lesson? Beer is all about what is in the glass at the end of the day but there are many routes to fill your glass. The sort of experimentation that requires exclusivity and high price is only one way to maybe get something interesting in hand.

    Did you say more pictures? You want more pictures? Bill of Oregon, the Bill of It's Pub Night, wrote to say "I'm not a great photographer, but I thought I'd waste your time with a few beery pictures." I am fine with that, happy to see them all as long as they are about beer... but I have to admit that I have no idea what is in that photo to the right. It could in fact be the worst entry ever. I like the hop picking ones even if they could be sharper.

    And Rob Symes of Toronto, Ontario forwarded these photos from Tokyo, Belgium and the UK.

    Fabulous. I quick like that window in the Cantillon attic. I am pretty sure someone else took a photo of a similar scene in earlier years. Can't find it. We've only had something near 700 entries over the years. How the heck and I supposed to find the one with the Cantillon window?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/11/25/Day_10__Catching_Up_With_The_Swollen_Inbox'

    Day 10: Catching Up With The Swollen Inbox

    Posted: November 25th, 2009, 1:06pm CET by Alan McLeod

    Things are moving along with the 2009 edition of the Yule and Sundry Holiday Beer Photo Extravaganza. Need more UK entrants. Not teaming with Jeff in London this year has meant a real hit given his huge following there. It's been a crippling blow to the knee caps, frankly. Maybe I need a photo of me sitting on a cask of beer. He has all the best ideas. Maybe I should consider that his own entry. Very Oor Wullie if you ask me.

    Ryan Hartigan of Vernon, NJ has sent in this aquatic photo to the right. The beer reference is rather subtle. Can you see it?

    Next, Zak Rotello of the Olympic Tavern in Rockford, Illinois has forwarded these five photos below from his Siebel class expeditions as well as this explanation of what's going on in each one:

    • Cantillon - a bung stopper on an active lambic barrel. every barrel had some sort of funk creeping out of the top.
    • Floetzinger - probably the best stop on the trip due to fact that the brewmaster cooked us a wonderful dinner with his wife, showered us with gifts, and basically showed us the absolute best hospitality of our lives.
    • Latrappe - brewer LJ Swinkels pouring a 750ml of their French oak aged Quad. we blamed him for making us late for the bus.
    • Oettinger - one of Germany's largest breweries; the scale of things in the brewhouse was mind-boggling, and this stack of empty bottle crates looks like a cityscape to me.
    • Augustiner - our home base while in Munich, the Augustiner Brau Stube (delicious schweinshaxe not pictured)

    Let me just say that those are some outstanding and exotic photographs of some classic European beer scenes... but don't I speak for all of us when I note, compared to Ryan's photo, that there is an utter absence of a fish in each and every submission? I am not going to pre-judge but one has to be honest about these things.

    Finally for now, Scott Mueller of Lawrence, Kansas forwards these five great shots.

    OK, no fish but ROBOT PAJAMAS! Gold. Pure gold.

    More later as I still have two more submissions in the queue. Thanks for you all taking the time to send these in. I will beat the bushes for more prizes and let you guys know what is on the table as soon as possible.

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/11/25/Nova_Scotians_Suddenly_Back_Away_From_The_Pub'

    Nova Scotians Suddenly Back Away From The Pub

    Posted: November 25th, 2009, 3:49am CET by Alan McLeod

    I hadn't heard this before but a sudden drop in bar attendance was discussed in today's Chronicle Herald:

    It could be fear of catching H1N1 or perhaps it’s a sign of the recession, but whatever the reason, pub-goers aren’t drinking beer in the quantities they used to. In general, beer sales by volume dropped by a dramatic 13.4 per cent in October. And in Nova Scotia, fewer people are drinking beer brewed at the Oland Brewery in particular, which means layoffs at the Halifax plant.

    The article does canvass some of the other issues going on with the regionally branded macro-lager plant - including the interesting observation that Nova Scotians try new beer more readily on tap in a pub. But one wonders of they tried to make a better class of beer whether they might grab some dwindling market share back. Note the production range: Keith’s India Pale Ale, Keith’s White, Keith’s Red, Keith’s Lite, Budweiser, Bud Lite, Oland, Schooner, Wildcat, Labatt Blue and Labatt Lite. Not a lot of variety there. Is this not 2007 auto industry thinking?

  • Permalink for 'A_Good_Beer_Blog/2009/11/24/Ontario__Two_Evenings_In_Dark_Bars_In_Toronto'

    Ontario: Two Evenings In Dark Bars In Toronto

    Posted: November 24th, 2009, 4:10am CET by Alan McLeod

    Beer culture is is such a delicate and hopefully early state of development in Canada - even after all these years - that there are only a few places you hope to find an important work related training course so that when the bell rings and class gets out, well, you have something to do. I found a couple of spots the last few days that did the trick.

    Feeling all very Ron, I got off the train last evening at around 9:00 pm and by one mere hour later had placed myself (after a little confusion from staff going off shift as to whether they were at work or not) at the upper room of the Queen and Beaver on Elm Street a half block away from the former site of Sam the Record Man. A sad testimony to the swath being cut through recorded music in Canada, the greatest record store in the land is but a hole in the ground now. But I didn't let it get me down. I have plenty of lps in the rec room to see me out. Instead, I planted myself in a wing chair and watched the second half of the MLS finals with a small group on a quiet Sunday night. At eight bucks a pint, it was not cheap but not insane either and when you can get a Denison's weissbier as well as McAuslan oatmeal stout things are not all that bad. Service upstairs was far better than the apparent social intrusion I made on the empty first floor. The neat and tidy English soccer themed rec room feel was great after being stuck on the train for a few hours. We need a society for wing chair appreciation. A society with beer taps.

    Tonight was a different matter as I walked up Yonge Street to hit the wonderful Cafe Volo. I met Troy Burtch of GCP'n'B there for supper. We got to chat with plenty of fine T.O. beer nerds as well as Ralph the owner and Michael Hancock of Denison's Brewing. Blab-blab-blab. Chatter-chatter-chat. Bought Troy late wedding gifts in the form of a share of a bottle of Pannepot as well as another of Nostradamus. Should his good bride point out that the gift only went to one half of the happy couple, well, I can only plead that once I gave a wah-wah pedal as a wedding gift.

    I had a County Durham Hop Addict which was very good as well as a Beau's Gabba Gabba Hey which was one wee notch gooderer and which got a solid three thumbs up from Michael. Five buck pints and the relaxed but seriously aware good beer atmosphere had the place hopping on a Monday night. Ralph was in the cellar beating on the casks at one point, the next telling us about his travels to Italy, then talking about how he was heading back to England for more training before he rolls out his own micro brewing on site. It was the place to be for good beer that night - busy when I wanted busy as much as the night before was quiet when I was whacked.

    These moments are few. I don't get out much so I am that much more tickled when they turn out to be just what I needed..